This is a special post for quick takes by anaguma. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Don't know how useful this is to note, but I tried opening up the automated transcript to help me follow along with the spoken debate, and within the first paragraph of doing so I saw:
I have updated enormously towards AI capabilities progress coming out of people doing alchemy rather than thinking carefully — heuristic-based search as opposed to poking-at-things-based search.
Is presented incorrectly. What is actually said in the transcript is:
Yud: I have updated enormously towards AI capabilities progress coming out of people doing alchemy rather than...
Irving: Thinking carefully?
Yud: Heuristic-based search. As opposed to poking-at-things-based search.
Implying alchemy = poking-at-things-based-search ≠ heuristic-based search ≈ thinking carefully. The way it's written in-transcript implies the positions of PaTBS and HBS would be swapped. This was pretty confusing, and if it's the first thing I saw in the transcript, I suspect the full thing contains other errors of similar degree. Given this, I think the transcript should be cleaned up (by hand, probably) before being turned into a top-level post.