On an apparent missing mood - FOMO on all the vast amounts of automated AI safety R&D that could (almost already) be produced safely
Automated AI safety R&D could results in vast amounts of work produced quickly. E.g. from Some thoughts on automating alignment research (under certain assumptions detailed in the post):
each month of lead that the leader started out with would correspond to 15,000 human researchers working for 15 months.
Despite this promise, we seem not to have much knowledge when such automated AI safety R&D might happen, in which order the relevant capabilities might appear (including compared to various dangerous capabilities), etc. AFAICT. we don't seem to be trying very hard either, neither at prediction, nor at elicitation of such capabilities.
One potential explanation I heard for this apparent missing mood of FOMO on AI automated AI safety R&D is the idea / worry that the relevant automated AI safety R&D capabilities would only appear when models are already / too close to being dangerous. This seems plausible to me, but would still seems like a strange way to proceed given the uncertainty.
For contrast, consider how one might go about evaluating dangerous capabilities and trying to anticipate them ahead of time. From GDM's recent Introducing the Frontier Safety Framework:
The Framework has three key components:
- Identifying capabilities a model may have with potential for severe harm. To do this, we research the paths through which a model could cause severe harm in high-risk domains, and then determine the minimal level of capabilities a model must have to play a role in causing such harm. We call these “Critical Capability Levels” (CCLs), and they guide our evaluation and mitigation approach.
- Evaluating our frontier models periodically to detect when they reach these Critical Capability Levels. To do this, we will develop suites of model evaluations, called “early warning evaluations,” that will alert us when a model is approaching a CCL, and run them frequently enough that we have notice before that threshold is reached.
- Applying a mitigation plan when a model passes our early warning evaluations. This should take into account the overall balance of benefits and risks, and the intended deployment contexts. These mitigations will focus primarily on security (preventing the exfiltration of models) and deployment (preventing misuse of critical capabilities).
I see no reason why, in principle, a similar high-level approach couldn't be analogously taken for automated AI safety R&D capabilities, yet almost nobody seems to be working on this, at least publicly (in fact, I am currently working on related topics; I'm still very surprised by the overall neglectedness, made even more salient by current events).
Intuitively, I'm thinking of all this as something like a race between [capabilities enabling] safety and [capabilities enabling dangerous] capabilities (related: https://aligned.substack.com/i/139945470/targeting-ooms-superhuman-models); so from this perspective, maintaining as large a safety buffer as possible (especially if not x-risky) seems great. There could also be something like a natural endpoint to this 'race', corresponding to being able to automate all human-level AI safety R&D safely (and then using this to produce a scalable solution to a... (read more)