Hot take, though increasingly moving towards lukewarm: if you want to get a pause/international coordination on powerful AI (which would probably be net good, though likely it would strongly depend on implementation details), arguments about risks from destabilization/power dynamics and potential conflicts between various actors are probably both more legible and 'truer' than arguments about technical intent misalignment and loss of control (especially for not-wildly-superhuman AI).
At the risk of being overly spicy/unnuanced/uncharitable: I think quite a few MIRI [agent foundations] memes ("which monkey finds the radioactive banana and drags it home", ''automating safety is like having the AI do your homework'', etc.) seem very lazy/un-truth-tracking and probably net-negative at this point, and I kind of wish they'd just stop propagating them (Eliezer being probably the main culprit here).
Perhaps even more spicily, I similarly think that the old MIRI threat model of Consequentialism is looking increasingly 'tired'/un-truth-tracking, and there should be more updating away from it (and more so with every single increase in capabilities without 'proportional' increases in 'Consequentialism'/egregious misalignment).
(Especially) In a world where the first AGIs are not egregiously misaligned, it very likely matters enormously who builds the first AGIs and what they decide to do with them. While this probably creates incentives towards racing in some actors (probably especially the ones with the best chances to lead the race), I suspect better informing more actors (especially more of the non-leading ones, who might especially see themselves as more on the losing side in the case of AGI and potential destabilization) should also create incentives for (attempts at) more caution and coordination, which the leading actors might at least somewhat take into consideration, e.g. for reasons along the lines of https://aiprospects.substack.com/p/paretotopian-goal-alignment.
[...]
I'm not particularly optimistic about coordination, especially the more ambitious kinds of plans (e.g. 'shut it all down', long pauses like in 'A narrow path...', etc.), and that's to a large degree (combined with short timelines and personal fit) why I'm focused on automated safety reseach. I'm just saying: 'if you feel like coordination is the best plan you can come up with/you're most optimistic about, there are probably more legible and likely also more truth-tracking arg
Thanks for spelling it out. I agree that more people should think about these scenarios. I could see something like this triggering central international coordination (or conflict).
(I still don't think this would trigger the USG to take different actions in the near-term, except perhaps "try to be more secret about AGI development" and maybe "commission someone to do some sort of study or analysis on how we would handle these kinds of dynamics & what sorts of international proposals would advance US interests while preventing major conflict." The second thing is a bit optimistic but maybe plausible.)