LESSWRONG
LW

532
Wikitags

Population Ethics

Edited by abramdemski last updated 18th Mar 2021

Population Ethics addresses the question: how should utilitarians deal with people coming in and out of existence? 

For example, a classical problem in population ethics: is it overall better for a happy person to exist, if they bring down the average happiness but increase the total? Those who would answer "yes" are termed total (hedonic) utilitarians; those who would answer "no" are termed average (hedonic) utilitarians.

Note that utility is not comparable, so we cannot simply speak of "increasing average utility" vs "increasing total utility". Hence, average utilitarianism vs total utilitarianism is not a well-defined distinction in the abstract; we have to specify e.g. hedonic utilitarianism before this distinction becomes well-defined (because average vs total happiness is a meaningful distinction).

However, although preference-utilitarians cannot necessarily make a meaningful distinction between averaging and totaling, they do not escape population-ethics dilemmas. It's still a fair question: when is it overall preferable to bring someone into existence (or for someone to pass out of existence)? What can/should ethics say about this?

Subscribe
Discussion
1
Subscribe
Discussion
1
Posts tagged Population Ethics
69Deminatalist Total Utilitarianism
Vanessa Kosoy
5y
56
3What if Ethics is Provably Self-Contradictory?
Q
Yitz
1y
Q
7
1Actualism, asymmetry and extinction
MichaelStJules
9mo
4
44Against neutrality about creating happy lives
Joe Carlsmith
5y
8
72Comparing Utilities
Ω
abramdemski
5y
Ω
31
34Debating myself on whether “extra lives lived” are as good as “deaths prevented”
HoldenKarnofsky
4y
9
32Why you, personally, should want a larger human population
jasoncrawford
2y
32
31UDASSA
Jacob Falkovich
3y
8
29Against population ethics
jasoncrawford
3y
39
24Population ethics and the value of variety
cousin_it
1y
11
19Example population ethics: ordered discounted utility
Ω
Stuart_Armstrong
7y
Ω
15
15Aging research and population ethics
emanuele ascani
6y
3
12Two kinds of population ethics, and Current-Population Utilitarianism
AlexMennen
11y
21
12Fertility Will Never Recover
Eneasz
8mo
31
6Is population collapse due to low birth rates a problem?
Q
mukashi, romeostevensit
3y
Q
36
Load More (15/27)
Add Posts