LESSWRONG
LW

Curated Posts

Archive Recommendations

Spotlight Items

Excerpts from a larger discussion about simulacra
Best of LessWrong 2019

Ben and Jessica discuss how language and meaning can degrade through four stages as people manipulate signifiers. They explore how job titles have shifted from reflecting reality, to being used strategically, to becoming meaningless.

This post kicked off subsequent discussion on LessWrong about

by Benquo
Load More
17Benquo
There are two aspects of this post worth reviewing: as an experiment in a different mode of discourse, and as a description of the procession of simulacra, a schema originally advanced by Baudrillard. As an experiment in a diffferent mode of discourse, I think this was a success on its own terms, and a challenge to the idea that we should be looking for the best blog posts rather than the behavior patterns that lead to the best overall discourse. The development of the concept occurred over email quite naturally without forceful effort. I would have written this post much later, and possibly never, had I held it to the standard of "written specifically as a blog post." I have many unfinished drafts. emails, tweets, that might have advanced the discourse had I compiled them into rough blog posts like this. The description was sufficiently clear and compelling that others, including my future self, were motivated to elaborate on it later with posts drafted as such. I and my friends have found this schema - especially as we've continued to refine it - a very helpful compression of social reality allowing us to compare different modes of speech and action. As a description of the procession of simulacra it differs from both Baudrillard's description, and from the later refinement of the schema among people using it actively to navigate the world.  I think that it would be very useful to have a clear description of the updated schema from my circle somewhere to point to, and of some historical interest for this description to clearly describe deviations from Baudrillard's account. I might get around to trying to draft the former sometime, but the latter seems likely to take more time than I'm willing to spend reading and empathizing with Baudrillard. Over time it's become clear that the distinction between stages 1 and 2 is not very interesting compared with the distinction between 1&2, 3, and 4, and a mature naming convention would probably give these more natural
simulacrum levels.
15Zvi
This came out in April 2019, and bore a lot of fruit especially in 2020. Without it, I wouldn't have thought about the simulacra concept and developed the ideas, and without those ideas, I don't think I would have made anything like as much progress understanding 2020 and its events, or how things work in general.  I don't think this was an ideal introduction to the topic, but it was highly motivating regarding the topic, and also it's a very hard topic to introduce or grok, and this was the first attempt that allowed later attempts. I think we should reward all of that.
471Welcome to LessWrong!
Ruby, Raemon, RobertM, habryka
6y
74
945AGI Ruin: A List of Lethalities
Ω
Eliezer Yudkowsky
3y
Ω
711
902Where I agree and disagree with Eliezer
Ω
paulfchristiano
3y
Ω
224
867Eight Short Studies On Excuses
Scott Alexander
15y
253
845Preface
Eliezer Yudkowsky
10y
17
787The Best Textbooks on Every Subject
lukeprog
14y
416
680What an actually pessimistic containment strategy looks like
lc
3y
138
678SolidGoldMagikarp (plus, prompt generation)
Ω
Jessica Rumbelow, mwatkins
2y
Ω
206
662AI 2027: What Superintelligence Looks Like
Ω
Daniel Kokotajlo, Thomas Larsen, elifland, Scott Alexander, Jonas V, romeo
3mo
Ω
222
646Simulators
Ω
janus
3y
Ω
168
131
Comparing risk from internally-deployed AI to insider and outsider threats from humans
Ω
Buck
2d
Ω
17
485
A case for courage, when speaking of AI danger
So8res
5d
118
268
Foom & Doom 1: “Brain in a box in a basement”
Ω
Steven Byrnes
8d
Ω
102
97
Proposal for making credible commitments to AIs.
Cleo Nardo
12d
42
154
X explains Z% of the variance in Y
Leon Lang
14d
32
224
Do Not Tile the Lightcone with Your Confused Ontology
Ω
Jan_Kulveit
18d
Ω
27
173
Futarchy's fundamental flaw
dynomight
21d
48
168
Estrogen: A trip report
cube_flipper
23d
41
81
A Straightforward Explanation of the Good Regulator Theorem
Alfred Harwood
1mo
29
142
Broad-Spectrum Cancer Treatments
sarahconstantin
1mo
10
150
The Best Reference Works for Every Subject
Parker Conley
1mo
27
266
Truth or Dare
Duncan Sabien (Inactive)
1mo
52
Load More