Is this comment anything more than playing on peoples' emotions and an appeal to authority? Who is Mike Darwin and why should I believe anything he says? Is he a doctor? Should I trust him because his last name is Darwin? Does he cite any statistics or make any claims that can be fact-checked in this quote? Is it proven that Aspirin CAUSES Reye's syndrome, as the quote claims? I usually appreciate your input gwern, but with this comment I've lost respect for you.
Is this comment anything more than playing on peoples' emotions and an appeal to authority?
Yes. It makes multiple easily falsifiable claims about aspirin, its effects, and history.
Who is Mike Darwin and why should I believe anything he says?...Should I trust him because his last name is Darwin?
2 seconds in google for 'mike darwin' would lead you straight to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Darwin which explains who he is, what he has done, and his real name, for that matter.
...Is it proven that Aspirin CAUSES Reye's syndrome, as the quote claims?
I recently recalled, apropos of the intermittent fasting/caloric restriction discussion, a very good blog post on mortality curves and models of aging:
gravityandlevity then discusses some simple models of aging and the statistical characters they have which do not match Gompertz's law:
What models do yield a Gompertz curve? gravityandlevity describes a simple 'cops and robbers' model (which I like to think of as 'antibodies and cancers'):
This offers food for thought about various anti-aging strategies. For example, given the superexponential growth in mortality, if we had a magic medical treatment that could cut your mortality risk in half but didn't affect the growth of said risk, then that would buy you very little late in life, but might extend life by decades if administered at a very young age.