110

LESSWRONG
LW

109
Personal Blog

-3

Why I Am Not a Technocrat

by Spugpow
20th Aug 2019
1 min read
4

-3

This is a linkpost for https://radicalxchange.org/blog/posts/2019-08-19-bv61r6/
Personal Blog

-3

Why I Am Not a Technocrat
12Viliam
2ChristianKl
1rsaarelm
1Pattern
New Comment
4 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 1:53 PM
[-]Viliam6y120

With an ad blocker, I see almost nothing on the page. No, I am not going to turn it off.

Reply
[-]ChristianKl6y20

The article treats highly autocratic leaders like Robert Moses, Mao and Stalin who had no desire to implement the recommendations from domain experts because they thought they knew better and who did their as being in the same reference of technocrats as people who push to make decisions on well-researched evidence-based models.

If that's what you need to argue to attack contemporary technocrats your case is very weak.

Reply
[-]rsaarelm6y10

Couldn't come up with a way to view the article. Downvoted without reading.

Reply
[-]Pattern6y*10

I'm interested in why the link was posted.

(I could read it via chrome.)

I didn't find the linked post very interesting, mostly because

1) I don't see a lot of self identified technocrats explaining their position - prior to reading this, I might have classified "RadicalxChange" as technocratic. Now I'd categorize them as "Technocrats who don't want to be called that."

2) Claims that aren't backed up, particularly of impossibility/intangibility, and similarly rejecting things without making it clear why (like consequentialism).

If an important task is impossible then we should give up. If it is possible, solutions seem like the place to start.

3) Saying 'one of the problems with Technocratic governance is focusing on legibility - with historically disastrous results.' And then following that up with 'We should fix Technocracy/governance by focusing on legibility...'

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Spugpow
View more
Curated and popular this week
4Comments