Pascal's reverse-mugging
One dark evening, Pascal is walking down the street, and a stranger slithers out of the shadows.
"Let me tell you something," the stranger says. "There is a park on the route you walk every day, and in the park is an apple tree. The apples taste very good; I would say they have a value of $5, and no one will stop you from taking them. However -- I am a matrix lord, and I have claimed these apples for myself. I will create and kill 3^^^3 people if you take any of these apples."
On similar reasoning to that which leads most people to reject the standard Pascal's mugging, it seems reasonable to ignore the apple-man's warning and take an apple (provided that the effort involved in picking it is trivial, assuming that Pascal knows that the apples are safe and legal to pick, etc.). However, I suggest that it intuitively seems more reasonable for Pascal to avoid taking the apples than it does for him to pay the mugger $5. However, this constitutes an act-omission distinction. I raise 3 possibilities: Either
One large difference between the scenarios is the answer to "what's in it for the stranger?"
In the standard Pascal's Mugging, the answer is "they get $5". Clear and understandable motivation, it is after all a mugging (or at least a begging). It may or may not escalate to violence or other unpleasantness if you refuse to give them $5, though there's a decent chance that if you do give them $5 then they'll bug you and other people again and again.
In this scenario it's much less clear. What they're saying is obviously false, but they don't obviously get much... (read more)