I did this same research project around 15 years ago when it was my partner's time to decide. My conclusion was that people who want kids are on average probably made slightly happier while those who have them by accident are probably made a good bit less happy. Few studies even give a guess at which is which.
That's taking happiness as momentary emotional state. I don't think even future you gets to judge whether you in the moment is happy.
I didn't keep notes, so fwiw. And there was a good bit of interpolation.
My now ex-partner had kids with someone who wanted them, and they seem pretty happy. And so do I.
Definitely agreed on this especially:
It’s also really important to distinguish between two groups:
- The child-free
- The childless
I don't have kids, didn't want to have kids, and am happy with that outcome.
I'd imagine also that having more or fewer kids than you want, or more difficulty in having them than people assume they 'should' have, will also have significant effects. And I would imagine, setting aside finances, that raising kids starting when you're in your early 20s and have more energy is a very different and more pleasant experience than having kids in your late 30s or 40s.
Also, when you are in your 20s, people keep telling you that there is enough time, and maybe you think like "1 or 2 kids is the right number". Then you have kids in your 40s and realize that actually you would prefer to have 3 or 4 kids... but now it's too late.
Having kids earlier has the advantage that you can still change your mind about how many. Leaving it for later limits your options. Many people probably do not realize this.
Societal support. Having children was more likely to make people happier or not affect their happiness on average if they lived in a country with generous parental support.
Depending on the type of parental support there are some conflicting results. Studies on multigenerational housing are very conflicted and hard to interpret, for example: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1155/hsc/7513142
I suspect (I've seen this personally but not seen any scientific studies about this) that it depends strongly on the cultural expectations that different households have w.r.t. how much autonomy the direct parents of a child get vs the grandparents in both their individual lives and child rearing.
Studies on multigenerational housing are very conflicted and hard to interpret
In my opinion, the optimal distance to grandparents is "close but separate", ideally the next house on the same street. On one hand, you have privacy at your home. On the other hand, it is awesome if your kids can safely walk to their grandparents alone.
Multigenerational housing sounds like it provides both big benefits and big costs. In the past I think most people lived like this, but also domestic violence was probably much more frequent. Probably still a net benefit for child raising, especially with lots of kids.
The general claim is that women are waiting too long to have kids. They have career but no family life, and this leaves them listless and wondering why they’re so sad and life feels empty. Some talk about men having this too, but it’s usually focused on women.
This would require serious research, which I cannot even imagine (how would you do experiments and control groups?), because opinions are of course abundant and strong, often politically flavored.
I think that for most people, taking care of their kids is the closest they ever get to "heroic responsibility". So it seems like there should be obvious differences between a society where most people experience this at 20, and where most people experience this at 40. Even if in the latter case most people would ultimately get the experience, it will still be different in the sense that at any given moment, most people alive did not have the experience yet.
As a trivial example, if you have small kids at home, you will probably strongly fight against working overtime. If most people are like that, it can create strong collective pressure against overtime. But if you are only one, you will probably be perceived as a slacker.
Similarly, social norms. If you have kids, or had them in the past, you will understand the need to make various places child-friendly. If you never had kids, then your default position is that people who have kids should be locked at home 24 hours a day so that they do not annoy the normal people -- no kids in supermarkets, restaurants, etc.
People who have kids are probably less likely to support war, or policies that are destructive in long term.
...but this is all just a guess. I'd like to have data.
These often come apart. For example, Scandinavia countries tend to score the highest in the world on life satisfaction, but Latin American countries tend to score the highest on emotional well-being.
Perhaps it would help to imagine some situations that are very high on one of these, and very low on the other.
High satisfaction, low emotional well-being -- working on a long and difficult project? (Yeah, kids are like that.)
High emotional well-being, low satisfaction -- browsing cat videos and posting memes, drug use?
This is probably imbalanced and I am missing some important things, so more examples would be appreciated.
People often report having kids as the most meaningful thing in their lives.
One great thing about having kids is that you can make it a one-off project. You get to the phase when your kids are grown up, and you can be like "I am happy that I have kids, and also happy that it's done and I do not have to do this again". (Something like doing PhD; you do it once, and then you have an accomplishment for life.)
I don’t see many people saying that their life feels empty because they couldn’t pick blackberries last August.
Because they probably satisfied their instinct in a supermarket. Many people enjoy shopping more than would be required for practical purposes. (Also, many childless people own pets.) Instincts are flexible, and capitalism is happy to redirect them towards something you can pay for.
some will regret having children.
Yeah.
I'd like to say that people should get some experience taking care of other people's kids, so see if they are fit for the job. But it's not the same. It is a different feeling when it's your child, genetically likely to grow up into a person similar to you, and you have the heroic responsibility for the project. Taking care of e.g. your older relative's child comes without the feelings of accomplishment. Plus you probably have to follow their instructions, so you don't have the autonomy that would naturally accompany the responsibility; in worst case, you may be treated like a child yourself, while taking responsibility for another literal child.
If you never had kids, then your default position is that people who have kids should be locked at home 24 hours a day so that they do not annoy the normal people -- no kids in supermarkets, restaurants, etc.
This seems obviously false. People who don't have or want kids still have the memory of having been kids themselves, and furthermore are perfectly capable of understanding claims such as "people different from me nevertheless have rights and get to exist in public, and that's a good thing".
We have words for people who prioritize their occasional annoyance over other people's freedom (or even lives). We call them psychopaths. It is certainly not the default case among humans. It is actually quite rare. It is an error of fact to ascribe pathological intolerance as "[your audience's] default position".
(I don't want a dog either ... yet I'm very glad that other people get to have dogs in my neighborhood.)
I have found in many areas of life that people who don't do X sometimes think that practitioners of X are being inconsiderate. For example, a big one that comes up often in my city - tradesmen drive big polluting diesel vans, why do they do that, why can't they just ride a bike, you can carry a toolbox on a cargo bike right? This is an actual debate that happens, as ridiculous as it sounds to anyone in the trades.
I think that in general people are more likely to put up with inconveniences if they personally do the same thing, tit for tat (I get to do this and the price is that you get to do this and mildly annoy me sometimes).
For example, the person who works on their car in their garage and makes weird sounds and fumes and so on is more likely to tolerate a neighbour doing the same. Or does guitar/piano practice, etc.
They just "get it" on a more visceral level. Small things like not understanding that (to a reasonable approximation) you can't just leave them at home, the kid is with you 24/7, which means that if you want to do a thing, the kid has to come with you, you can't just save it and reload later.
People who don't have or want kids still have the memory of having been kids themselves
I don't think people have realistic memories of what it was like when they were e.g. 5 or younger.
Similarly, consider education, when most people think they are experts because they were pupils once.
My first thought while reading this was "I bet this is going to depend a lot on how much of a financial burden it is for you to have kids". I just clicked on one of the studies you linked, (Blanchflower & Clark 2021), and, sure enough, the sign flipped to a small but significant positive correlation if you controlled for difficulty in paying bills. And that is just based on answers to "From time to time difficulty paying bills" and "Most of the time difficulty paying bills". There's still a large gap between being able to pay your bills most of the time and having enough spare income to support a child (much less multiple children). That study at least likely isn't able to effectively distinguish people who can comfortably afford children from those who can't.
In fact, if you assume that people are able to make more or less rational decisions when it comes to having children (much easier with widely available contraception), then seeing little to no correlation between having children and life satisfaction is exactly what you would expect. I think that is more or less happening - people are making fairly rational decisions regarding having kids (though far from perfect, some do regret their choice as you say).
The more interesting question to me is whether more people would be happier with children if money was not a factor. If this were the case, you would predict that beyond a certain level of income, increasing income correlates with more children. A quick google search suggests that is true - there is a "reverse J-shaped" curve which looks to be reproduced fairly well across studies, though I didn't dig too deep into it. (The reverse J shape just means that the slope starts off downward [negative correlation] and then eventually flips to point upward [positive correlation] as you increase income or a related measure along the x-axis, with fertility rate on the y-axis.)
Women are evolved to be mothers. Men are evolved to be fathers.[1]
So does that mean if people don’t have kids, they’ll be less happy? Less fulfilled?
I hear this claim a lot in the right wing sphere of bloggers and podcasts. See the excellent blogger Psychobabble for an example of this, or on the wonderful Modern Wisdom podcast.
The general claim is that women are waiting too long to have kids. They have career but no family life, and this leaves them listless and wondering why they’re so sad and life feels empty. Some talk about men having this too, but it’s usually focused on women.
Since I generally find Psychobabble and Modern Wisdom to be quite wise, I decided to do a deep dive into this question. Are people less happy without children?
Heads up, I am a bit biased or perhaps the best person to be writing about this, depending on how you look at it. I’m a 36 year old woman and I really do not want kids. However, I know this running up towards the end of my fertile years, so if I’m going to decide, it’s got to be now.
Of course, even if on average people are happier with kids, that doesn’t mean I should have kids specifically. People are not averages. I know my situation and self far better than a statistic based on thousands of people.
Same goes for you. If you had kids and they made you happier, that’s probably true for you. It’s also true if it made you less happy.
However, it’s still interesting. Let’s dive in.
The short answer is: having kids doesn’t make you happier on average
It also probably doesn’t change mental health outcomes on average.
It’s really important to understand what the “on average” means. Some women get post-partum depression. Some women are bathed in such deep love that they describe the newborn phase as the best part of their life.
Bell curves and averages don’t mean most people are the average. In fact, 50% of people are above average and 50% of people are below average. Only a tiny fraction of people are actually the “average”.
Let’s start with some important distinctions too. There are two general measures of happiness:
These often come apart. For example, Scandinavia countries tend to score the highest in the world on life satisfaction, but Latin American countries tend to score the highest on emotional well-being.
You can also have weird responses for emotional well-being, where it’s common to have more positive and negative emotions (Deaton & Stone 2014).
So how does parenting do on these metrics? It’s quite plausible that it reduces emotional well-being, adding stress, anxiety, sleeplessness, and financial struggles, but it increases life satisfaction. People often report having kids as the most meaningful thing in their lives.
You’d also expect us to have evolved to enjoy having kids. People who didn’t like having kids were less likely to invest in their care and they would be more likely to fail to survive and reproduce.
But hey, women are also evolved to pick berries and men are evolved to hunt, and I don’t see many people saying that their life feels empty because they couldn’t pick blackberries last August.
So what do the studies say?
Roughly speaking, it’s a mess. There are about as many studies saying parents have the same life satisfaction, less, and more, clustering around no effect.[2] When they do find a difference, the effect sizes are tiny (Hansen et al. 2009; Blanchflower & Clark 2021).
On the emotional well-being front, it’s similarly all over the place. Some studies show that parents have more positive and negative emotions (Deaton & Stone 2014). Some studies show no difference (Hansen et al. 2009). Some track over the day where they ask how they happy they are while they’re doing it, and people report enjoying taking care of kids about as much as doing household chores (Kahneman et al. 2004).
What about mental illness? Psychobabble makes the claim that not having kids is making women mentally ill. Maybe that is happening but not showing up in the happiness stats?
Interestingly, non-parents do show more mental illness, specifically depression and anxiety, than parents (Andersen et al. 2026; Helbig et al. 2006). But parents more symptoms of depression and anxiety (Andersen et al. 2026; Evenson & Simon 2005)? I honestly don’t know how to interpret that. Surely if you have more symptoms, then you’d have higher rates? Maybe parents are just having chronic low grade symptoms and non-parents tend to be more extreme and bimodal?
But this raises a chicken and egg question: does having kids protect you against mental illness, or do mentally ill people have less children?
There’s some evidence that people who struggle with depression have lower fertility rates (Andersen et al. 2026). There are also interesting studies where they compared three groups:
They found that people who were planning to kids had less mental illness than people who had kids, and the rates increased once they did have kids (Andersen et al. 2026). This points towards that it’s more likely that if you’re struggling with depression, you’re less likely to have kids.
It’s also really important to distinguish between two groups:
Did you decide to not have kids? Or did you want to have them and failed to, either through inability to find a suitable partner in time or infertility?
(Not to mention voluntary vs involuntary birth. Having kids on purpose vs by accident surely must have an effect.)
In most studies both people are put in the same box of no-children, but there’s every reason to expect them to be deeply different. Having a strong desire constantly thwarted is bound to make anybody sad. And I’ve read accounts of people dealing with their longing for kids and it breaks my heart.
Meanwhile, I am child-free by informed choice and I’m jetsetting around the world as a digital nomad and absolutely cherishing my freedom. Whenever I hear a child screaming, I say a little prayer of thanks that I didn’t have kids with my ex-husband. If I think of spending a year changing nappies and being sleep deprived instead of writing and exploring, that seems like a total waste and loss of meaningful work, not more. Surely my happiness rates are going to be different from somebody who’s gone through multiple rounds of IVF to have a child.
Of course, it also depends on why you’re childless vs childfree. Some people are childfree because they think the world is on fire and they don’t want to bring a child into that, or you think humans are plague on the environment. Some people are childless because they were so enmeshed in a career they’re so passionate about that they missed the boat. You’d expect very different emotional profiles on each of these.
As always, there is so much diversity and complexity in psychology
Unfortunately, there aren’t many studies on this, but the evidence does support the general direction that voluntary child-freeness feel better than the involuntarily so (Jeffries & Konnert 2002; Connidis & McMullin 1993; Gameiro et al. 2014).
What about regret? Won’t childless people regret not having kids?
The short answer: yes, some will. And some will regret having children.
Across the studies asking parents if they regretted or somewhat regretted having children, it ranged from 4.7-20% (Newport & Wilke 2013; YouGov 2016; YouGov 2021; Piotrowski 2021; Meil et al. 2023). If you want some great portrayals of what it feels like to regret children, I highly recommend the movie The Lost Daughter. The Marriage Story and The Letdown both don’t show regretting children but it shows why one might and are very well done. Also check out r/regretful parents where people discuss their own experiences.
I also think regretting having children is going to be underreported. For one, many will simply not let themselves even think it. It would be too devastating to them and would probably make them a worse parent. Not to mention there is so much stigma about this that it will lead to more self-delusion and less reporting of the experience.
Across the studies asking non-parents if they regretted not having children, it ranged from roughly 20-50% (Newport & Wilke 2013; Greil et al. 2022; Minkin et al. 2024; Stegen et al. 2025). Of course, they usually didn’t distinguish between voluntary and involuntary childlessness, which totally ruins the data. Another interesting study showed people who never wanted children reported no more life regret than parents (3.30 vs 3.87, not significant) (Watling Neal & Neal 2023). This is regretting anything about life, rather than kids specifically. Which might be pointing out that some people just regret choices more retrospectively.
So overall, there is a risk you’ll regret it. This is more common among the childless than the parents, but it’s really hard to tell if that’s just mixing together the voluntarily and involuntarily childless.
Other interesting confounding variables:
Conclusion: it depends
Overall, the evidence points to that, on average, having kids doesn’t not change your happiness. Of course keeping in mind that almost no individual is average. For a large percentage of people, having kids will have made them moderately happier. For a large percentage of people, having kids will have made them moderately less happy. And for a small percentage, it will either have dramatically changed their lives for the better and others, for the worse.
So unfortunately we cannot look to the science to decide whether having kids will be a good choice for you. Although I do think you can do some minor, imperfect taste-testing first. Try taking care of nieces or nephews for a few nights or take up babysitting for a bit. See if you like the reality as much as the idea of it. (That’s how I ended up deciding against children, despite previously deeply wanting them.) But in the end, you’ll just have to decide to take the jump or not. It’s up to you as individual.
If you enjoyed reading this, you might enjoy:
Cross-posted from my Substack where I write about a wider variety of things.
Yes, it’s not just women who have parental instincts. Read more about it in this excellent book A Billion Years of Sex Differences. Fascinating read.
(No difference: Bhargava et al. 2014, Deaton & Stone 2014, Watling Neal & Neal 2021. Negative difference: Glass et al. 2016, Nelson-Coffey et al. 2019, Blanchflower & Clark 2021. Positive difference: Hansen et al. 2009, Nelson et al. 2013).