This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
The top posts in the 2018 Review are filled with fascinating and well-explained ideas. Many of the new ideas are not settled science, but they're quite original and substantive, or excellent distillations of settled science, and are often the best piece of writing on the internet about their topics.
You're wrong about LW epistemic standards not being high enough to make solid intellectual progress, we already have. On AI alone (which I am using in large part because there's vaguely more consensus around it than around rationality), I think you wouldn't have seen almost any of the public write-ups (like Embedded Agency and Zhukeepa's Paul FAQ) without LessWrong, and I think a lot of them are brilliant.
I'm not saying we can't do far better, or that we're sufficiently good. Many of the examples of success so far are "Things that were in people's heads but didn't have a natural audience to share them with". There's not a lot of collaboration at present, which is why I'm very keen to build the new LessWrong Docs that allows for better draft sharing and inline comments and more. We're working on the tools for editing tags, things like edit histories and so on, that will allow us to build a functioning wiki system to have canonical writeups and explanation that people add to and refine. I want future iterations of the LW Review to have more allowance for incorporating feedback from reviewers. There's lots of work to do, and we're just getting started. But I disagree the direction isn't "a desperate effort to find the truth". That's what I'm here for.
Even in the last month or two, how do you look at things like this and this and this and this and not think that they're likely the best publicly available pieces of writing in the world about their subjects? Wrt rationality, I expect things like this and this and this and this will probably go down as historically important LW posts that helped us understand the world, and make a strong showing in the 2020 LW Review.