This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Quoting your reply to Ruby below, I agree I'd like LessWrong to be much better at "being able to reliably produce and build on good ideas".
The reliability and focus feels most lacking to me on the building side, rather than the production, which I think we're doing quite well at. I think we've successfully formed a publishing platform that provides and audience who are intensely interested in good ideas around rationality, AI, and related subjects, and a lot of very generative and thoughtful people are writing down their ideas here.
We're low on the ability to connect people up to do more extensive work on these ideas – most good hypotheses and arguments don't get a great deal of follow up or further discussion.
Here are some subjects where I think there's been various people sharing substantive perspectives, but I think there's also a lot of space for more 'details' to get fleshed out and subquestions to be cleanly answered:
The above isn't complete, it's just some of the ones that come to mind as having lots of people sharing perspectives. And the list of people definitely isn't complete.
Here examples of things that I'd like to see more of, that feel more like doing the legwork to actually dive into the details:
Eli Tyre and Bucky replicating Scott's birth-order hypothesis
Katja and the other fine people at AI Impacts doing long-term research on a question (discontinuous progress) with lots of historical datapoints
Jameson writing up his whole research question in great detail and very well, and then an excellent commenter turning up and answering it
Zhukeepa writing up an explanation of Paul's research, allowing many more to understand it, and allowing Eliezer to write a response
Scott writing Goodhart Taxonomy, and the commenters banding together to find a set of four similar examples to add to the post
Val writing some interesting things about insight meditation, prompting Kaj to write a non-mysterious explanation
In the LW Review when Bucky checked out the paper Zvi analysed and argued it did not support the conclusions Zvi reached (this changed my opinion of Zvi's post from 'true' to 'false')
The discussion around covid and EMH prompting Richard Meadows to write down a lot of the crucial and core arguments around the EMH
The above is also not mentioning lots of times when the person generating the idea does a lot of the legwork, like Scott or Jameson or Sarah or someone.
I see a lot of (very high quality) raw energy here that wants shaping and directing, with the use of lots of tools for coordination (e.g. better collaboration tools).
The epistemic standards being low is one way of putting it, but it doesn't resonate with me much and kinda feels misleading. I think our epistemic standards are way higher than the communities you mention (historians, people interested in progress studies). Bryan Caplan said he knows of no group whose beliefs are more likely to be right in general than the rationalists, this seems often accurate to me. I think we do a lot of exploration and generation and evaluation, just not in a very coordinated manner, and so could make progress at like 10x–100x the rate if we collaborated better, and I think we can get there without too much work.