This is a special post for quick takes by daijin. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
People say AI improves labour productivity, but there are actually two labour productivities:
1. For any given person, compare their productivity with and without AI. This is dProductivity / dAI
2. For any given marginal person added to the humans plus AI labour pool, what is the extra value they would add. This is dProduction / dPerson.
When we say: “AI Improves productivity!” It means dProductivity / dAI is positive, and that is true. However, quality of life is correlated to the second figure: dProduction / dPerson. If dProduction / dPerson is positive, we hire more people, have more babies, and feel secure in our jobs. What is AI doing to dProduction / dPerson? I think it is reducing it.
Both things can be true: AI can increase productivity, and AI can simultaneously make quality of life worse.
On an individual scale, of course it is good to have access to AI. On a social scale, providing AI to everyone makes everyone’s life awful, even if you make it free and awesome. But there’s a prisoner’s dilemma: if you don’t use AI, your competitors will, and they will be able to outcompete you.
There are two solutions to the prisoner’s dilemma, in a broad sense. The mathematical solution to a one-time prisoner’s dilemma is to betray; this is by construction.
The metagame solution to the prisoner’s dilemma, without changing the game, is playing it over and over. Knowing that you’ll play again tomorrow makes trust and cooperation the long term strategy. Or at least, if the maths works out [1].
Follow up questions:
1. Why is AI reducing dProduction / dPerson?
2. For your answer to 1, does it have to be this way?
3. You could replace [AI] with [any other technology]. So haha, this is actually a post about governance, wrapped in AI. Have we ever succeeded in governing the rollout of a new technology, and if so, how did we do it?