LESSWRONG
LW

Progress StudiesWorld Modeling
Frontpage

18

Progress links and tweets, 2023-07-06: Terraformer Mark One, Israeli water management, & more

by jasoncrawford
6th Jul 2023
2 min read
4

18

This is a linkpost for https://rootsofprogress.org/links-and-tweets-2023-07-06
Progress StudiesWorld Modeling
Frontpage

18

Progress links and tweets, 2023-07-06: Terraformer Mark One, Israeli water management, & more
6bhauth
2Sean Aubin
1bhauth
4Lao Mein
New Comment
4 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 4:25 AM
[-]bhauth2y60

I like Casey Handmer, but...

  • US natural gas today: $5/MCF
  • CO2 from air: >$8/MCF
  • H2 from electrolysis: >$37/MCF

As those posts say, biomass conversion and electrochemical reforming of methane seem much more economically practical.

Reply
[-]Sean Aubin2y*20

FYI, Terraform Industries published a new blog post about the cost of their hydrogen electrolysis, which is significantly less than you're linked estimate of around $7/kg. They claim they can get $3/kg using current legacy solar, but with current solar cost trends continuing (which I know you're skeptical of) could reach $1.12/kg. They accomplish this by optimizing the cost/efficiency trade-off of the electrolysis setup.

I'm assuming Casey Handmer is being overly optimistic, but I can't tell by how much.

Reply
[-]bhauth2y10

I don't think Terraform can produce 50% efficient durable electrolyzers that cheaply. So, who's right?

You've seen my blog. I linked to a post that linked to some papers on electrolysis costs.

Casey also has a blog. Here's the background of their initial team:

Casey Handmer PhD. Casey earned his PhD in gravitational wave simulation from Caltech in 2015. He designed maglev systems at Hyperloop and built GPS science instruments and mapping tools at NASA JPL before founding Terraform Industries.

David Smyth worked on software for the Space Shuttle and JPL Mars rovers, before stints at Millennium Space Systems and Honeybee Robotics. He’s also the President of Westlawn Institute of Marine Technology.

Stephanie Coronel PhD. Stephanie completed her PhD studying mechanics of composite fuel tank ignition prevention at Caltech, followed by work on combustion safety at Boeing and Sandia National Laboratory.

Jenna Amundson brings deep experience with marketing and people ops from Hyperloop and Jenlis.

We’re also proud to work with Second Group Design engineers Brian Towle (GE, Hyperloop) and Jett Ferm (Pilot Group, Hyperloop) to fine tune our carbon filter.

So, how would you go about evaluating who's right, here?

Reply
[-]Lao Mein2y40

I have a suspicion about why DNA is base 4 vs base 2.

It has to do with the binding strengths of tRNA to mRNA during translation. Base 2 increases the length of codons needed to code for 23 amino acids from 3 to 5, which may lead to less fidelity in the resulting amino acid sequence. That is, partial matches have higher binding strength compared to base 4, which increases the chances the wrong tRNA is loaded. This could also make longer amino acid sequences harder to create - an accidentally loaded stop codon terminates translation!

Reply
Moderation Log
More from jasoncrawford
View more
Curated and popular this week
4Comments

Opportunities

  • Free virtual course for people in tech who want to work on biology (via @kulesatony)

News

  • A background of gravitational waves pervades the cosmos (via @QuantaMagazine)
  • The Terraformer makes cheap natural gas from sunlight & air (via @TerraformIndies)

Obituaries

  • Henry Petroski, “America’s poet laureate of technology,” author of To Engineer is Human, The Evolution of Useful Things, and other books
  • John Goodenough, age 100 (!) “His discovery led to the wireless revolution and put electronic devices in the hands of people worldwide”

Links

  • Great SpaceX video about iterating towards reusable rockets (via @pronounced_kyle)
  • Scott Alexander on the “illusion of moral decline” (but see Matt Clancy’s pushback)
  • Three auto maintenance philosophies, from @stewartbrand’s book in progress
  • As the opportunity cost of time increases, so does our concern about wasting time
  • How to do great work (by @paulg)
  • The “undercurrent of tacit knowledge” in any scientific literature (by Tyler Cowen)
  • GLP-1 drugs are amazing for weight loss, says Derek Lowe (via @curiouswavefn)
  • Why you can ignore the “aspartame causes cancer” headlines (by @StuartJRitchie). Related, the IARC puts bacon in the same category as plutonium

Queries

  • What use cases is hydrogen best for? And what are the front-runners for long-term energy storage?
  • What are the best films about capitalism, business, and market economics?
  • Why does DNA use base 4 rather than base 2 for encoding information?
  • How to roll back as much bad regulation as possible in one tweet?
  • Any indicators of misuse threat of adversarially fine-tune-able 10^25 LLMs?
  • What intellectuals refocused New Left types towards remaking the physical world?

Quotes

  • Real history is not politics but the story of those who make a better life
  • Academics and nonprofits act as if someone else will translate their papers into policy

Tweets & threads

  • The saga of Israeli water management
  • A biodefense roadmap from Kevin Esvelt. Excellent work
  • Chicago went all in on railroads and Cincinnati went all in on canals
  • A path to prosperity for small cities within one hour of a major city/airport
  • Update from prediction market Kalshi on regulated election markets
  • I push back against Dustin Moskowitz’s list of AI safety “strawmen”
  • Many good ideas are killed for reasons unrelated to their promise
  • As we make progress on social problems, we broaden the definition of the problem. A case of the Shirky Principle
  • In 1844, the Secretary of the Navy was killed during a military demonstration
  • Most attempts to disrupt education do project-based learning, which is overrated
  • SF can’t even find actual collisions to cite against self-driving cars
  • As Bezos says: “Let me assure you, this is the best planet”
  • “We can’t answer every question.” “No, but I think we can answer any question.”

Charts

  • The US electrical grid has been getting less reliable for decades

  • How many ships Bethlehem Steel built during WWII