From my reader's perspective, Inkhaven was probably bad. No shade to the authors, this level of output is a lot of work and there was plenty I enjoyed. But it shouldn't be a surprise that causing people to write a lot more posts even when they're not inspired leads to a lot more uninspired posts.
A lot of the uninspired posts were still upvoted on LW. I even did some of that upvoting myself, just automatically clicking upvote as I start reading a post with an interesting first paragraph by someone whose name I recognize. Mostly this is fine, but it dilutes karma just a bit more.
And I only ever even saw a small fraction. I'm sorry if you were an Inkhaven author who killed it every time, I was merely being shown a subset, since I mostly just click on things on the front page. Probably not so much sorted by quality as by network effects that can get onto the front page long enough to snowball upvotes.
I think as a reader I'd have liked the results better if participants had to publish every other day instead.
My guess is you're the only person in the world who does this, but also this is better than what everyone else is doing and maybe I should start doing it
2Erich_Grunewald
It wasn't clear to me from the Inkhaven website that you, Ben Pace, and John Wentworth were participating to that degree (though I did mention you three), and I missed aggliu and RobertM. So fair enough, I'll retract my comment. (ETA: I missed aggliu since I didn't know their name and they had only that one LW post in November, and I thought RobertM might be Rob Miles, but none of RobertM's November LW posts seem to be listed among Rob Miles's posts on the Inkhaven website. But obviously you were there and I was not so I defer to you.)