One thing that's misleading about LLMs is that they have actual scaling laws with compute, which are distinct from the possible experience curve things that are also happening. And all of this is happening at some pace over time, so time also gets conflated with scale. My model is basically that progress should be thought of as happening depending on scale, not depending on time; and that gradual algorithmic progress is more like an experience curve effect that therefore slows down if/when scaling slows down. This just doesn't say anything about paradigm-shifting innovations, which can happen at any moment and very quickly lead to strong ASI. (So my contrarian take is that slow takeoff is actually slow rather than fast, while fast takeoff remains very fast indeed even after years of observing a slow takeoff.)