This is a special post for quick takes by Thomas Kwa. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
The author of "Where Is My Flying Car" says that the Feynman Program (teching up to nanotechnology by machining miniaturized parts, which are assembled into the tools for micro-scale machining, which are assembled into tools for yet smaller machining, etc) might be technically feasible and the only reason we don't have it is that no one's tried it yet. But this seems a bit crazy for the following reasons:
The author doesn't seem like a domain expert
AFAIK this particular method of nanotechnology was just an idea Feynman had in the famous speech and not a serious proposal (he introduces it with "let me suggest one weird possibility")
Investment in the Feynman Program, if it's feasible, would pay off quickly, since there are large economic benefits to the incremental microtechnologies (getting halfway there at a reasonable price would essentially produce any manufactured good that doesn't require nanoscale processes, which seems like most of them, while also increasing quality).
In particular, semiconductor manufacturing started at the micro-scale, and many companies converged on lithography for manufacturing rather than using miniature robots. Then we invented MEMS, which is machinery created using lithography-like processes, and chip factories never switched from lithography to MEMS. We never even progressed from MEMS to fully general microtechnology.
Does anyone with domain expertise have further thoughts?
I think a MEMS engineer would be better suited to evaluate whether the engineering problems are feasible than a computer scientist / futurist author. Maybe futurists could outdo ML engineers on AI forecasting. But I think the author doesn't have nearly as detailed an inside view about nanotech as futurists on AI. There's no good answer in the book to the "attention bottleneck" objection JBlack just made, and no good story for why the market is so inefficient.
[...]
These are all ideas of the form "If we could make fully general nanotechnology, then we could do X". Gives me the same vibe as this. Saying "nuclear reactor. . . you have hydrogen go through the thing. . . Zoom! it's a rocket" doesn't mean you can evaluate whether a nuclear reactor is feasible at 194X tech level, and thinking of the utility fog doesn't mean you can evaluate whether MEMS can be developed into general nanotech at 202X tech level.
2Gunnar_Zarncke
Thank you for this comprehensive answer. I like the requirement of "actual practical accomplishments in the field".
Googling a bit I found this article on miniaturization:
https://www.designnews.com/miniaturization-not-just-electronics-anymore
Would you consider the cited Thomas L. Hicks from American Laubscher a domain expert?