This is a special post for quick takes by Thomas Kwa. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
LLMs are good enough at physics that we'll soon be able to use them to red-team Drexlerian nanotech and actually see if it's feasible, settling the question once and for all (and long before we actually attempt to build it).
Some years ago, LW user Muireall found that GHz mechanical nano-computers probably don't work [1], but it's not clear if this objection transfers to other nanotech. I think that GPT-5.6 could, with a sufficient token budget, make a lower quality but still acceptable version of this analysis for the rest of Nanosystems, and within 6 months make something of the same quality but going into far more detail with minimal human effort.
[1] I believe this for a variety of reasons, happy to share.
Note that Merkle et. al (2025) have proposed atomically precise FETs, claiming that their design would allow for computers with 10^25 SOPs[1]/cm^3 (using only 10 watts[2], though at 10MHz). Transistor physics is a much more settled science than nanomechanics, and I did not see any glaring issues in their technical notice (though my background in physics is limited). However, when I did ask GPT-5.6 (high reasoning, not Pro) to check the notice, it stated that 'several claims are physically incorrect or substan... (read more)