How does cryonics make sense in the age of high x-risk? As p(doom) increases, cryonics seems like a worse bet because (1) most x-risk scenarios would result in frozen people/infrastructure/the world being destroyed and (2) revival/uploading would be increasingly likely to be performed by a misaligned ASI hoping to use humans for its own purposes (such as trade). Can someone help me understand what I’m missing here or clarify how cryonics advocates think about this?
I'm signed up for Alcor.
I straightforwardly agree that the more likely I am to die of x-risk, the less good of a deal, probabalistically, cryonics is.
(I don't particularly buy the cryonics patients are more likely to be utilized by misaligned superintelligences than normally living humans. Cryopreserving destroys structure that the AI would have to reconstruct, which might be cheap, but isn't likely to be cheaper than just using intact brains, scanned with superintelligently developed technology.
But, yep, to the extent that living through an AI takeover might entail an AI doing stuff with your brain-soul that you don't like, being cryopreserved also exposes you to that risk.)
I see here is that if there's a delay between when uploads are announced and when they occur, living people retain the option to end their lives.
Seems correct that cryonics patients have a lot less ability to flexibly respond to the situation compared to alive and animate people.[1]
I don't think that this is a very decisive consideration. I expect that whatever series of events will cause the superintelligence to get the most of what it wants in expectation is the series of events that will play out.
It's astonishingly weird if the superintelligence prefers... (read more)