It seems to me that many smart people could ignore the existing literature on pedagogy entirely and outperform most people who have obtained a formal degree in the area (like highschool teachers), just by relying on their personal models. Conversely, I'd wager that no-one could do the same in physics, and (depending on how 'outperforming' is measured) no-one or almost no-one could do it in math.
I would assume most people on this site have thought about this kind of stuff, but I don't recall seeing many posts about it, and I don't anyone sharing their estimates for where different fields place on this spectrum.
There is some discussion for specific cases like prediction markets, covid models, and economics. And now that I'm writing this, I guess Inadequate Equilibria is a lot about answering this question, but it's only about the abstract level, i.e., how do you judge the competence of a field, not about concrete results. Which I'll totally grant is the more important part, but I still feel like comparing rankings of fields on this spectrum could be valuable (and certainly interesting).
From my short experience, teaching in classroom if often less about transmitting information and more about maintaining order (but without maintaining order, transmission of information becomes impossible).
While this is true, reading the existing literature on pedagogy might be as helpful for maintaining order as reading the computer science literature for typing fast.
A lot about what being a good teacher is about isn't about being smart but emotional management. That means things like being consistent with students and not acting from a place of being emotionally triggered by students.
2Dagon
Ok, I see where I disagree, then. I don't think a smart person who's avoided training and research about teaching can teach an average class better than a somewhat less smart person who's trained and studied how to teach. Probably better than a dumb person, and where the point of indifference is I don't know.
I don't think it's feasible to know physics or math very well without research and study of prior art, so I don't think that's an evaluatable claim. There are probably some math problems where raw IQ can get someone through, but never as well as somewhat less smart and actual study.