I’ve been putting off writing a blog post that seems very important to me, because it seems important, and so should be done on a later day when I am a better person, and able to do it justice. Also, once I have written one or two other posts that should precede it. Which also I’m not up to today. Noticing the uneasy wrongness of all that, I set out to write the blog post anyway, badly, today.
But less than a sentence in, I remembered that I heard that maybe someone else had written something like this. And one ought not write what someone else has written, it seemed, at least without framing it like that: ‘I am summarizing this argument by Alice’.
In the past, I might have unproductively Googled a bit for it, then gone on to write my blog post. But now I thought: perhaps AI could tell me? So I asked. Yes, it said, that has been thoroughly written about, and gave me some papers. In the blogosphere? Yes, and it gave me some blog posts.
In the process of this discussion, I learned that others’ stances on it seem importantly wrong to me, and so there are still natural things to say to help the public conversation get to a correct view. But now the natural thing to do is to read these other pieces, and reference them, and post as a correction in a conversation with them. And that is less punchy and reaches a different audience. And overall, I think will just be worse. A post that states a complete view with no regard for what has been said before or how it relates to them would I think be a better artifact here.
So why not just write that anyway? I suppose because it seems strange to not acknowledge an existing conversation, and ignorant and silly to write about a topic that others are discussing without bothering to learn what they are saying at all. It’s embarrassing to say something everyone’s been talking about for a while as if it is new. So it is tempting to at least learn enough about the state of conversation that I can mention it here and there, even if trying to keep the overall discussion accessible to those not deep in the debate.
But learning about the conversation is time consuming, so the post goes back to the pile of really important ones I don’t have time to do justice to right now. And what would be added—references to existing discussion, coherence with that literature, a check on my arrogance—probably doesn’t add much for most readers.
So overall this seems perhaps an unfortunate development. And not deeply the fault of AI, to be clear—if it would be better for me to just write the post without reference to the literature, then the deeper problem is probably the norms and sensibilities that push me against that. But given those deeper problems, help from AI is a hindrance: AI makes it easier to find out about literature, which brings more topics into the realm where I feel obliged to read literature before writing about the topic. And if everyone knows about the change, then choosing not to ask AI doesn’t help you. You can’t opt out of the equilibrium changing.
Part 1 (or Article 1), write your own thoughts, almost as you would do if you did no research.
Part 2 (or Article 2), respond to what other people wrote.
State your position first, because if you start engaging with others, you may never get to stating your position clearly. But then, other people's posts are as if pre-written replies to you.
Do you use the AIs to help you read? I've been doing this more and more (and then spotchecking stuff to make sure the AIs aren't lying to me/strawmanning the original work), especially for work that I suspect isn't very good but I should still be aware of.
This is frustrating, and a big reason why I haven't written more things than I have. Trying to figure out how to overcome/move past it. If anything I've found AI somewhat helps with this though because it makes it lower cost (though still substantial cost) to engage with existing literature: easier to find, easier to sort through.
My favorite writings are journeys not destinations. If you will only ever write one thing on a topic, then yes learn about it.
If you are willing to return, then own your starting point as having heard of the topic but not explored what others are saying yet. Write your own piece, then revisit and see what their takes information in you and what you would or would not change now that you have additional points of view.
When working with AI this is my workflow. I have my position first. I ask for the AI input, then I see where we agree and don't. I push it and ask it to push me. Then I get a synthesis. But I always start with my place independently arrived, and I don't give it to the AI when I ask it to makes its position.
You have this in your situation but with other humans. They have their position written independently from you, and you can write yours independently from them. There is a lot of value in that as a starting point. If you are willing to revisit the topic.
I’ve been putting off writing a blog post that seems very important to me, because it seems important, and so should be done on a later day when I am a better person, and able to do it justice. Also, once I have written one or two other posts that should precede it. Which also I’m not up to today. Noticing the uneasy wrongness of all that, I set out to write the blog post anyway, badly, today.
But less than a sentence in, I remembered that I heard that maybe someone else had written something like this. And one ought not write what someone else has written, it seemed, at least without framing it like that: ‘I am summarizing this argument by Alice’.
In the past, I might have unproductively Googled a bit for it, then gone on to write my blog post. But now I thought: perhaps AI could tell me? So I asked. Yes, it said, that has been thoroughly written about, and gave me some papers. In the blogosphere? Yes, and it gave me some blog posts.
In the process of this discussion, I learned that others’ stances on it seem importantly wrong to me, and so there are still natural things to say to help the public conversation get to a correct view. But now the natural thing to do is to read these other pieces, and reference them, and post as a correction in a conversation with them. And that is less punchy and reaches a different audience. And overall, I think will just be worse. A post that states a complete view with no regard for what has been said before or how it relates to them would I think be a better artifact here.
So why not just write that anyway? I suppose because it seems strange to not acknowledge an existing conversation, and ignorant and silly to write about a topic that others are discussing without bothering to learn what they are saying at all. It’s embarrassing to say something everyone’s been talking about for a while as if it is new. So it is tempting to at least learn enough about the state of conversation that I can mention it here and there, even if trying to keep the overall discussion accessible to those not deep in the debate.
But learning about the conversation is time consuming, so the post goes back to the pile of really important ones I don’t have time to do justice to right now. And what would be added—references to existing discussion, coherence with that literature, a check on my arrogance—probably doesn’t add much for most readers.
So overall this seems perhaps an unfortunate development. And not deeply the fault of AI, to be clear—if it would be better for me to just write the post without reference to the literature, then the deeper problem is probably the norms and sensibilities that push me against that. But given those deeper problems, help from AI is a hindrance: AI makes it easier to find out about literature, which brings more topics into the realm where I feel obliged to read literature before writing about the topic. And if everyone knows about the change, then choosing not to ask AI doesn’t help you. You can’t opt out of the equilibrium changing.