This is a special post for quick takes by alkjash. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
My last twoposts seem to be the most unpopular things I've ever written. Are they actually unusually bad somehow or is it just the LLM blocks turning people off?
I use LLMs for some fact-checking and line-editing at the end of each writing session; both posts detect as 100% human-written in pangram. Would it be dishonest to just drop the LLM content blocks?
To me it was more that they both looked like "Basic points on AI safety" type posts (the "Why focus on extinction risk" post is not exactly that, but to the extent that it isn't I disagreed somewhat and didn't find it particularly insightful otherwise).
Sorry, just to reiterate, the LLM generated few of the words but did help with some minor editing.
My AI safety essay was flagged for LLM content (I think because I had Claude generate the references and links), so I started putting everything I write in LLM content blocks to not deal with the headache.
I think this was an overreaction.
2Dagon
Hmm. I didn't look that closely at the formatting/generation - my reaction wasn't "this is AI, and I hate it", it was "this is not worth reading, and it looks like AI is the cause", which may mean I'm the wrong audience and you should ignore my comments. Or it may mean that the content actually isn't compelling, separate from how much AI was used for it.
I see you've edited it, so it's clearer that it's your voice. That's good, but it still doesn't match my interests for the site. It doesn't clearly state a position or exposition of facts, or even a non-trivial model for thinking about something. Or maybe it's about "how to convince a norm" rather than about "what is Altman's strategy" or "what are my beliefs" or "how should you form beliefs here". I am less interested in the messaging/advocacy topic, and it's not clear without reading closely that this is what it is. And my caveat above applies even more: I'm only one reader, others have different criteria.
A better title and thesis statement (or even summary at the bottom) would perhaps make it more useful for people who are interested, and easier to ignore for those who aren't.