This is a question for the people working on more foundational research. My underlying objective is loose and in the future and is something like "figure out a good basis to describe collective intelligence and agency and then improve that so that we can incorporate AI into our collective systems". I therefore believe that the question of how a collective agent is formed is very important. I also find it very important to figure out the properties of good systems in terms of institutions in terms of information theory.
There's a lot of foundational ground to cover here and I'm worried that I'm stepping in the wrong direction so to keep myself grounded I try to talk to academics and researcher in the fields I'm trying to study and unify (compositionally). I'm getting these local reward signals about whether things make sense, I also post these things on LW and substack yet I find the signal to be quite sparse in various ways or at least uncorrelated with what I would consider progress for myself.
The classic good ol advice is to backchain from your end states you want, to run experiments, to think about the real world and if things are true there. I've done this in the past and now it feels like I'm at a point where I kind of need to take a step of faith in what I've done so far and I wanted to know if there's some tips from people who have taken this sort of step of faith in the past. How long did you find your exploration to be useful? If you did it again for yourself, what would you do differently?
The actual question is something like: Do I go down the route of discretizing collective intelligence through something like koopman operators, renormalization groups or something similar? How do they relate to things like active inference and game theory? What about spectral graph theory? Could actually all Collective Intelligence be expressed as graphs? There's like at least 6 different relatively deep mathematical ways I've found that you can express these systems through and I've got no clue which one to dive deeper into.
I know part of the direction where I want to go (expressed as a fancy schmancy thing here: https://eq-network.org/roadmap/ ) but the foundation stage is predecessor of the rest and it seems quite important to get right and it's just really difficult so if anyone has any thoughts I would be very happy to hear them.
There are times when all you need to do is synthesis of established knowledge that's distributed among people who don't talk with each other. I think my latest post on hyaluranon fall into that category. I think there's value in getting research together to build a gears model and adding new labels. There's no new fundamental insight in it. That's different for other work I'm doing that's actually about persuing insights.
It might very well be that the key problem you want to solve in amendable to just synthesizing existing knowledge of other people. It mig... (read more)