I'm done with LessWrong. I'm leaving. Seeing one of the administrators advocate violence against AI lab employees, and seeing the userbase upvote and agree-vote his comment on net, has made me no longer want to spend time on the site or be associated with it. That comment is a particularly strong example of a pattern I've been observing on LessWrong recently, and it's tipped me over into deciding to stop visiting the site.
In the past couple years I've noticed a trend of increasing dogmatism on LessWrong, where some users have become intolerant of disagreement with the cluster of beliefs according to which AI extinction is highly likely, timelines are short, and pause/stop advocacy is necessary to survive. In the past couple months this trend has gotten noticeably worse. It's turned into a purity spiral that's now starting to turn against prosaic AI alignment researchers: I've noticed a more posts and comments lately that discuss, often in with-us-or-against-us social terms, whether prosaic alignment research and the people who do it are acceptable. From the vote counts on most of those posts, the "no" side appears to be winning.
Some of you are probably thinking something along the lines of, "But AI really will kill us all, and soon. Isn't radicalism justified in circumstances like these?" If something like that comes to mind for you, I'd like to request that you take a moment to consider the perspective of someone with a significantly different worldview. How would you sound to them? Set aside, for a moment, your cached objection to the term "outside view" and try taking it. Learn from history what groups tend to do when their members have orthodoxic commitments to beliefs in apocalyptic stakes.
(And how did that objection to "outside view" end up in your cache in the first place? What purpose might the objection serve, to you... or someone else?)
I've gotten practical value out of LessWrong in the past. After leaving, I'll end up missing some posts I would've liked to read. LessWrong used to succeed as a place for people to improve their rationality. But now I've come to think that it's having the opposite effect now that people here are using arguments as soldiers so frequently. Most of the times I visit LessWrong nowadays it leaves my mind unsettled and my thinking less clear. I feel the need to defend, to myself, my disagreements with the emerging doctrines and feel as though I'm about to be exposed as an impostor. My local rationalist and EA group doesn't have the same problems I mentioned, and I'll continue to engage with it. But continuing to use LessWrong has become counterproductive to me. To improve my truth-seeking abilities and learn to act more wisely, I've decided to leave this site behind.