This is a special post for quick takes by Quinn. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I feel like half the reasons people tell me they like my newsletter is that I basically write how I talk, which is a voice, which is a "meat certificate" (reasons my readers believe I'm not using AI too much), which has gotta be an important part of my relationship with readers since its dead easy to make a slop current events newsletter anymore.
The thing is--- I have memories dating back to the beforetimes of people telling me my verbal tics were "bad writing". Often people line edit my writing to turn it into "good writing" and it hobbles the voice. Slop itself and especially our reactions to it are kinda proof that "good writing" in its extremes is grotesque or offputting.
I'm wondering how far up this goes.
the effortpost version of this would have examples, i'm jotting down a quick note instead
There's writing that's "good" in that it has actively pleasant/shiny/lively traits to it, and there's writing that's "good" because it lacks for bad qualities; it's too informal, uses too many semicolons, uses weird dialectical constructions, that kind of thing. People too often fail to see the distinction and ruin the former in seeking the latter.