As I write this, there are around 3 hours left before polls close for this years's New York's 12 District Democratic Primary. If you're a registered democrat in NY-12, you can still vote.[1]
But for those of us who reside elsewhere, there's little to be done but to wait with bated breath. Will Alex Bores, author of the RAISE act, manage to overcome the millions of dollar spent against him by Leading the Future and demonstrate that AI regulation is not just politically viable but a winning issue? Or will the establishment favorite (and favorite from the start of the race) Micah Lasher succeed in succeeding his mentor Nadler?
I don't know. As of writing, the prediction markets (Kalshi, PredictIt) have Bores winning at around 28% and Lasher at 72%. If you think you do know the answer, you should go make some money on these markets!
One thing I'm worried about is that people will learn too much from the binary outcome of Bores or Lasher and not on the details of the race. I'm writing this in haste to get it out before the polls close, and we start seeing the outcome, so as to preregister my thoughts.
If Bores loses, some might claim that AI regulation remains politically toxic, and that LTF's spending was decisive. (I imagine LTF certainly will.) But this is a mistake: win or lose, Bores's demonstrated that passing AI regulation will not just leave you facing down millions of dollars of Super PAC spending alone. Instead, millions of dollars of Super PAC money was spent on ads championing Bores (in fact, more than what LTF spent!), as well as hundreds of thousands of dollars of donations from AI Safety-concerned individuals.
I know many people who've donated to Bores's campaign, and who are invested in his victory. If he were to lose -- especially by a large margin -- it might seem tempting to dismiss the whole enterprise of political donations entirely. Similarly, if (somehow) he were to win by a large margin, it might feel like the marginal donation was useless. But I think this too is a mistake.
Ultimately, you can only make decisions based on the information you have. Eric Neyman's expected value math is correct, and reasonable ex ante. In close elections, even small efforts can help make the difference, and ex ante, this election had a good chance of being very close. If Bores were to lose, or win by a large margin, at most this tells us that his judgment of whether the election would be close was wrong, and even then not by very much.
I am busy, so I do not have time to write a beautiful conclusion or polish this piece. Personally, I hope that despite the unfavorable prediction market odds, Bores wins. But I didn't write this as an action to affect that outcome. Instead, I wrote it to preregister my claims, such that they're not seen as post hoc cope after the election results come in.
Nonetheless, here's my attempt at a conclusion, written in one go:
A phrase I think about a lot these days is the Chinese idiom 尽人事,听天命 (lit. [after you] exhaust human efforts, [then] heed heaven's mandate (fate)).[2] In the end, all you can do, as a single person in this very large world, is do everything within your power, and then wait with bated breath for the outcome. Unlike the English equivalents (e.g. "Man proposes, Heaven disposes."), it's fundamentally an optimistic (or at least motivational) idiom, not a fatalist one.
Rgardless of the outcome -- which is outside of the control of any one person, even Bores or Lasher -- there will be more elections and political battles to come. Regardless of the outcome, I hope the people around me take the right lesson from the NY-12 election, and continue to do their best, instead of simply resigning to fate.
Consult https://ny12.org/ if you need help finding your polling station!
Claude Opus 4.8 suggests that it should be translated as "Do everything within human power, then accept the will of heaven.".
You can remove it by downvoting your own react. Not sure if it works with reactions that other people have already voted on though.