About a month ago, after some back-and-forth with several people about their experiences (including on lesswrong), I hypothesized that I don't feel the emotions signalled by oxytocin, and never have. (I do feel some adjacent things, like empathy and a sense of responsibility for others, but I don't get the feeling of loving connection which usually comes alongside those.)
Naturally I set out to test that hypothesis. This note is an in-progress overview of what I've found so far and how I'm thinking about it, written largely to collect my thoughts and to see if anyone catches something I've missed.
Under the hypothesis, this has been a life-long thing for me, so the obvious guess is that it's genetic (the vast majority of other biological state turns over too often to last throughout life). I also don't have a slew of mysterious life-long illnesses, so the obvious guess is that's it's pretty narrowly limited to oxytocin - i.e. most likely a genetic variant in either the oxytocin gene or receptor, maybe the regulatory machinery around those two but that's less likely as we get further away and the machinery becomes entangled with more other things.
So I got my genome sequenced, and went looking at the oxytocin gene and the oxytocin receptor gene.
The receptor was the first one I checked, and sure enough I have a single-nucleotide deletion 42 amino acids in to the open reading frame (ORF) of the 389 amino acid protein. That will induce a frameshift error, completely fucking up the rest of protein. (The oxytocin gene, on the other hand, was totally normal.)
So that sure is damn strong evidence in favor of the hypothesis! But, we have two copies of most genes, including the oxytocin receptor. The frameshift error is only on one copy. Why isn't the other copy enough for almost-normal oxytocin signalling?
The frameshift error is the only thing I have which would obviously completely fuck up the whole protein, but there are also a couple nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the ORF, plus another couple upstream. So it's plausible that one of the SNPs messes up the other copy pretty badly; in particular, one of them changes an arginine to a histidine at the edge of the second intracellular loop. (Oxytocin receptor is a pretty standard g-protein coupled receptor, so that's the mental picture here.) I did drop the sequences into alphafold, and I don't see any large structural variation from the SNPs, but (a) that histidine substitution would most likely change binding rather than structure in isolation, and (b) this is exactly the sort of case where I don't trust alphafold much, because "this is one substitution away from a standard sequence, I'll just output the structure of that standard sequence" is exactly the sort of heuristic I'd expect a net to over-rely upon.
It's also possible-in-principle that the second receptor copy is fine, but the first copy frameshift alone is enough to mess up function. I think that's unlikely in this case. The mRNA for the frameshifted version should be removed pretty quickly by nonsense-mediated decay (I did double check that it has a bunch of early stop codons, NMD should definitely trigger). So there should not be a bunch of junk protein floating around from the frameshifted gene. And the frameshift is early enough that the messed up proteins probably won't e.g. form dimers with structurally-non-messed-up versions (even if oxytocin receptor normally dimerizes, which I'd guess it doesn't but haven't checked). At worst there should just be a 2x lower concentration of normal receptor than usual, and if there's any stable feedback control on the receptor concentration then there'd be hardly any effect at all.
Finally, there's the alternative hypothesis that my oxytocin signalling is unusually weak but not entirely nonfunctional. I do now have pretty damn strong evidence for that at a bare minimum, assuming that feedback control on receptor density doesn't basically counterbalance the fucked up receptor copy.
Anyway, that's where I'm currently at. I'm curious to hear others' thoughts on what mechanisms I might be missing here!
I have read that some sequencing methods (nanopore) have a high error rate (comparing multiple reads can help correct this). Did you also spot-check some other genes that you have no reason to believe contain mutations to see if they look ok? Seeing a mutation in exactly the gene you expect is only damn strong evidence if there isn't a sequencing error in every third gene.
EDIT: Looks like this was checked, nice: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/Hds7xkLgYtm6qDGPS/how-i-learned-that-i-don-t-feel-companionate-love