LESSWRONG
LW

Robotics
Personal Blog

4

Link: Open-source programmable, 3D printable robot for anyone to experiment with

by polymathwannabe
29th Oct 2014
1 min read
8

4

Robotics
Personal Blog

4

Link: Open-source programmable, 3D printable robot for anyone to experiment with
2Gunnar_Zarncke
4ChristianKl
1Gunnar_Zarncke
3V_V
2Gunnar_Zarncke
1V_V
1ChristianKl
1Gunnar_Zarncke
New Comment
8 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 11:10 AM
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke11y20

What I'm really interested in is the 3D-printable 3D-printer. But a robot is half of the way. And needed to fill in the PLA.

Reply
[-]ChristianKl11y40

RepRap is something like a 3D-printable 3D-printer. On the other hand a 3D printer won't print you computer chips anytime soon.

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke11y10

Yes. I wonder about the minimum infrastructure needed to create computing hardware comparable to modern ICs.

Reply
[-]V_V11y30

There exist lots of off-the-shelf programmable ICs, from single-board microcontrollers to FPGAs.
Why would you need to print your own custom ICs?

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke11y20

Because you can't create ICs yourself? You know a clockmaker (mechanical clocks) can create his own tools and working mechanical clocks in the farthest backwaters with only steel rods and his suitcase of tools (not very large; I have seen one). I admit that creating refined steel requires some more sizable - but nothing technologically advanced.

The same cannot be said about any part of modern electronics. Sure. You can print your case yourself. Sure, you can layout your board yourself. But you still depend on extremely highly integrated ICs and/or FPGAs. This means that if civilization collapses it falls down to mechanical tools - because those can be created locally with 'minimum' tools (at least where this knowhow was left). If not for the ICs we could have the same for electronics. Thus this could reduce an Xrisk.

Reply
[-]V_V11y10

Ah ok, I hadn't understood the context of your question.

Reply
[-]ChristianKl11y10

Producing 10000 units of a computer chip usually isn't 10000x times as expensive as producing 1 unit. There are huge first unit hardware costs.

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke11y10

Of corse. But if you know the minimum infrastructure and its price you can choose intermediates.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from polymathwannabe
View more
Curated and popular this week
8Comments

Its name is Poppy.

"Both hardware and software are open source. There is not one single Poppy humanoid robot but as many as there are users. This makes it very attractive as it has grown from a purely technological tool to a real social platform."