Immortality and identity.
https://philpapers.org/rec/TURIAI-3
Abstract:
We need understanding of personal identity to develop radical life extension technologies: mind uploading, cryonics, digital immortality, and quantum (big world) immortality. A tentative solution is needed now, due to the opportunity cost of delaying indirect digital immortality and cryonics.
The main dichotomy in views on personal identity and copies can be presented as: either my copy = original or a soul exists. In other words, some non-informational identity carrier (NIIC) may exist that distinguishes the original from its exact copy. Typically, it is often claimed that NIIC is either continuity of consciousness, soul, perspective, sameness of atoms, or position in space. We create an exhaustive map of identity theories.
To resolve the main dichotomy, we must recognize that personal identity requires an overarching validating system: God, qualia world, social agreement, blockchain or evolutionary fitness. This means that we cannot solve identity without solving metaphysics (and the nature of time). It is unlikely we'll solve this before creating superintelligent AI.
Therefore, a conservative approach to personal identity is preferable: as we don't know the nature of identity, we should preserve as much as possible and avoid situations similar to Mars Teleporting unless necessary for survival.
There are several tricks which can help us answer identity-related problems without solving all needed metaphysics; these tricks are variants of the conservative approach:
There are other possible tricks: branching identity, bundle and self-repairing identity, gradual identity, and identity in MWI. All of them do not solve the hard problem of identity.
We suggest a hypothetical test for identity theories: quantum Mars Transporter: if copy ≠ original, I will always experience broken Mars transporter.