Similar to the monthly Rationality Quotes threads, this is a thread for memorable quotes about Artificial General Intelligence.
- Please post all quotes separately, so that they can be voted up/down separately. (If they are strongly related, reply to your own comments. If strongly ordered, then go ahead and post them together.)
- Do not quote yourself.
- Do not quote comments/posts on LW/OB.
Vernor Vinge
Edsger Dijkstra (1984)
It is seemingly easy to get stuck in arguments over whether or not machines can "actually" think.
It is sufficient to assess the effects or outcomes of the phenomenon in question.
By sidestepping the question of what, exactly, it means to "think",
we can avoid arguing over definitions, yet lose nothing of our ability to model the world.
Does a submarine swim? The purpose of swimming is to propel oneself through the water. A nuclear powered submarine can propel itself through the oceans at full speed for months at a time. It achieves the purpose of swimming, and does so rather better than a fish, or a human.
If the purpose of thinking is isomorphic to:
Model the world in order to formulate plans for executing actions which implement goals.
Then, if a machine can achieve the above we can say it achieves the purpose of thinking,
akin to how a submarine successfully achieves the purpose of swimming.
Discussion of whether the machine really thinks is now superfluous.
"Sorry Arthur, but I'd guess that there is an implicit rule about announcement of an AI-driven singularity: the announcement must come from the AI, not the programmer. I personally would expect the announcement in some unmistakable form such as a message in letters of fire written on the face of the moon." - Dan Clemmensen, SL4
Michael Anissimov
Samuel Butler (1872)
Eliezer Yudkowsky (2008)
Arthur C. Clarke (1968)
"There are lots of people who think that if they can just get enough of something, a mind will magically emerge. Facts, simulated neurons, GA trials, proposition evaluations/second, raw CPU power, whatever. It's an impressively idiotic combination of mental laziness and wishful thinking." - Michael Wilson
Vernor Vinge
... in original.
Alan Turing (1951)
Theodore Roosevelt
I.J. Good (1970)
Norbert Weiner (1949)
"In the universe where everything works the way it common-sensically ought to, everything about the study of Artificial General Intelligence is driven by the one overwhelming fact of the indescribably huge effects: initial conditions and unfolding patterns whose consequences will resound for as long as causal chains continue out of Earth, until all the stars and galaxies in the night sky have burned down to cold iron, and maybe long afterward, or forever into infinity if the true laws of physics should happen to permit that. To deliberately thrust you... (read more)
Stephen Hawking
Garet Garrett (1926)
AAAI PRESIDENTIAL PANEL ON LONG-TERM AI FUTURES: 2008-2009 STUDY, Interim Report from the Panel Chairs
Good (1965)
The use of "unquestionably" in this quote has always irked me a bit, despite the fact that I find the general concept reasonable.
Samuel Butler (1863)
Konstantin Kakaes
George Dyson (1998)
Now we just need machines on our side and we'll have a cute little love-triangle.
T.M. Georges (2004)
Why we're doomed reason #692...
Here is Hugo de Garis, in the opening of The Artilect War:
I.J. Good (1970)
Samuel Butler (1880)
Bill Gates
I am the psychotherapist. Please, describe your problems. Each time you are finished talking, type RET twice.
I feel so tired
Why do you say?
I fall asleep all the time
Is it because of your plans that you say?
Yes, I work too hard
Maybe your life has something to do with this.
Indeed!
Can you elaborate on that?
Well, I work so can improve my life
What makes you believe?
I read it somewhere
Is it because of the people you hang around with that you say?
I bet it is because of that
I would appreciate it if you would continue.
[...]
my secretary will send you a bill.
-- ema... (read more)
Margaret Boden, Artificial Intelligence and Natural Man, p. 463
Wozniak declared to his audience that "we're already creating the superior beings, I think we lost the battle to the machines long ago."
http://au.ibtimes.com/articles/157802/20110606/steve-wozniak-humans-will-soon-surrender-superiority-to-machines.htm
Kevin Warwick (1998)
Julius Lukasiewicz (1974)
James Barrat
-Yvain
Cade (1966), p. 225
Cade (1966), p. 220
Page 223 includes this drawing of self-reproducing machines.
Samuel Butler, 1872
(My own answer to Butler's question is "No" for the reason Moravec gave in 1988.)
Ray Kurzweil, The Age of Spiritual Machines, p. 3
Al-Rodhan (2011), pp. 242-243, notices the stable self-modification problem.
From Michie (1982):
... (read more)Woody Bledsoe, quoted in Machines Who Think.
Crevier, AI: The Tumultuous History of the Search for Artificial Intelligence, p. 341
I.J. Good (1998)
Peter Kugel
James Barrat
Havelock Ellis, 1922
Steve Torrance (2012)
Cade (1966), p. 228
Shorter I.J. Good intelligence explosion quote:
Source.
Albert Einstein
"... This is the subject matter of Fun Theory, which ultimately determines the Fate of the Universe. For if all goes well, the question "What is fun?" shall determine the shape and pattern of a billion galaxies." - Eliezer Yudkowsky