As per the advanced chess obituary, we have a rough idea of the length of the centaur stage for chess. But what do we know of the length of the centaur stage for other games? I sent off Claude 4.6 Sonnet for a deep research query, here's the result (sorted by domains with an identifiable gap on top):
(Claude-generated table starts here [1] )
| Domain | AI ≈ human (year) | Centaur stage start | Centaur stage end | Calendar duration | Evidence quality | Post-centaur exploitation | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Go | 2016 | 2016 | ~2017 | ~0–1 yr | Low | Yes: Wang et al. 2022 | Community consensus, no primary tournament data |
| Chess | ~1997 | ~1998 | ~2013–2016 | ~15–18 yr | Medium | unknown | Advantage eroded continuously from ~2009 |
| Protein (single-domain) | ~2020 (AF2) | ~2018 | ~2020–2022 | ~2–4 yr | High | unknown | CASP15: no significant human advantage on single-domain |
| Weather forecasting | ~2003 (ensembles) | unclear | ~2003–2005 | very short / nil | High | unknown | Humans beat single models but not ensembles, even in 2003 |
| Checkers | 1994 (Chinook) | ~1994 | ≤2007 | <13 yr (upper bound) | Low | unlikely (game solved) | Tinsley drew Chinook 1994, winning in 1990; weakly solved 2007 sets hard upper bound |
| Radiology (ICH) | not yet | ~2019–2020? | ongoing | 5+ yr and counting | High | N/A (Type 1 ongoing) | AI still substantially below human parity as of 2024 |
| Dermatology | ~2018 | ~2019–2020 | ongoing | ~5–6 yr and counting | High | N/A (Type 1 ongoing) | Meta-analysis n=67,700; human+AI > human alone |
| Protein (multi-chain) | not yet | ~2020? | ongoing | 4+ yr and counting | High | N/A (Type 1 ongoing) | Significant human advantage on assembly targets (p=0.029) |
| Software function completion | ~2021–2023 | unclear | ongoing? | unclear | Medium | N/A (Type 1 ongoing?) | Workplace RCT null; lab studies show 42–56% gains |
| Shogi | ~2013 | ~2013? | ~2015? | ~2 yr? | Very low | unknown | Speculative; no controlled data found |
| Backgammon | ~1992 (TD-Gammon) | unknown | unknown | unknown | None | unknown | No centaur tournament literature found |
| Poker (HUNL) | ~2017 (Libratus) | unknown | unknown | unknown | None | unknown | No controlled human+AI vs. AI-alone data found |
| Machine translation | ~2018–2020 (NMT) | ~2016? | unclear | unclear | None | unknown | Post-editing claims refuted by adversarial verification |
| Legal (contract review) | unknown | unknown | unknown | unknown | None | unknown | No controlled data found |
| Financial trading | unclear | unclear | unclear | unclear | None | unknown | No controlled centaur-vs-AI-alone literature found |
| Scientific synthesis | emerging | unclear | unclear | unclear | None | unknown | LLM-assisted systematic reviews under study; no benchmarks |
(Claude-generated table ends here)
Apologies for the lack of collapsible section. Switching to the rich text editor (plausibly buggily?) fails :-) ↩︎
The idea of a centaur stage suggests a solution to both AI-human and human-human alignment. Just stay in the centaur stage indefinitely. Make sure that everyone stays useful. If you scale AI intelligence, also scale human intelligence to keep them in check. If you scale biological human intelligence, if you want to maximize fairness, you would want to raise the waterline as much as possible and reduce variance in IQ. In practice we might have limited time. Both human empowerment and human disempowerment are attractors. We are already fairly far into the di... (read more)
Covaries with notes.