[Review] Edge of Tomorrow (2014)

I once saw a fan theory that made me see the movie in a whole new light.

How could Emily Blunt know that the transfusion made her lose her time travel powers - after all, she's never been able to test it.
Therefore, how could Tom Cruise know that the time loop made him lose his time travel powers.
Therefore, Emily and Blunt are still in the time loop. They've "succeeded", but the moment one of them dies, they'll find themselves back at the beginning of the same day.

There's a Naruto fanfic (much better than the actual manga, mind) with this trope, except the author adds a cool extra at the end. In that, it turns out one with looping power only goes back to the same point in time because

they haven't learned how to set a new, so to speak, "save point". This mechanic became clear to the characters after they had decades of experience in child bodies, so that they began to carefully plan the world they wanted to have, and exhaustively time looped until they managed to set things perfectly aligned for the next stage of their plan, at which point they "saved", and went for it.

[-]Gyrodiot4y10

If I'm correct and you're talking about

Time Braid

you might want to add spoiler tags.

[-]alexgieg4y10

I've tried adding spoiler tags, but it isn't working. According the FAQ for Markdown it's three colons and the word "spoiler" at the beginning, followed by three colons at the end, but no luck. Any suggestion?

[-]lsusr4y30

It's a paragraph-level operator. You need a newline after the ":::spoiler" and before the three colons at the end. Inline spoilers tags don't work.

:::spoiler
demo
:::

[-]alexgieg4y10

Thanks! And done! :-)

[-]alexgieg4y10

I think that was the one, yes. It's been years and I forgot the name.

I'll add the tags, thanks!

Act 1

In the first scene, Tom Cruise goes through his day normally. He dies and comes back to life. He relives the same day over and over until he gets used to how the time loop works. At the end of Act 1, Tom Cruise discovers that war heroine Emily Blunt used to have the time travel power too and they team up.

Act 3

In Act 3 Tom Cruise loses his time travel power. Together, he and Emily Blunt have only one shot to kill the boss alien.

Act 1 and Act 2 make sense. They're structurally identical to Groundhog Day. But Act 3 is awful. This is a time travel movie. In Act 3 there's no time travelling! It turns into a generic action flick.

What happened?

All You Need is Kill

Edge of Tomorrow was originally based on the Japanese light novel All You Need is Kill. Act 1 and Act 2 are the same. I hypothesize Act 3 was modified for American audiences.

In All You Need is Kill, Emily Blunt never loses her time travelling power. She fights alongside Tom Cruise as an equal. They kill the boss alien together.

But the story doesn't end there.

In All You Need is Kill there is a detailed explanation about how the time travel works. To escape each time loop our heroes need to kill the alien loopers, leaving only themselves. But since both Tom Cruise and Emily Blunt are both loopers, only one of them can escape the final time loop. One of them has to die.

So at the end of the story there's a big epic duel to the death between our two heroes who love each other and have spent the entire story training and fighting alongside each other.

That is how you end a time travel samurai epic.

LESSWRONG
LW

LESSWRONG
LW

21

[Review] Edge of Tomorrow (2014)

21

21

Spoiler-Free tl;dr

Spoilerific Review

Act 1

Act 2

Act 3

All You Need is Kill