LESSWRONG
LW

Meetup : Any Salt Lake City residents who might be interested in a meetup? — LessWrong

2 Meetup : Any Salt Lake City residents who might be interested in a meetup?

by adamisom

12th Dec 2011

1 min read

2

Personal Blog

2

New Comment

27 comments, sorted by

top scoring

Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 7:33 PM

[-]LWMormon14y170

What a great idea. I would be interested in seeing if any fellow Mormons will be attending? I have been studying a lot of the work on Bayes by Tim McGrew and have been applying it to the claims of the Mormon church. With well adjusted priors the evidence seems pretty good! I recommend the influential work on Bayes done by Tim and Lydia McGrew.

[-]HeatDeath14y40

As a non-Mormon Christian the application of Bayesian principles to religious claims, particularly claims made by ancient documents where the primary evidence is no longer available is of great interest to me. I hope I can make it. Work may have me traveling in late January though. :(

[-]MachismoDaddy14y140

Me too. I second the idea of exploring how the McGrews apply Bayes to religious claims. Then we can contrast that with how someone like Richard Carrier uses them against religious claims. I think the difference in uses will be enlightening.

[-]CarlShulman14y20

I recommend the influential work on Bayes done by Tim and Lydia McGrew.

Past Less Wrong discussion did not paint a favorable picture of their 'Bayesian apologetics': arbitrarily restricted sets of hypotheses, abuse of dubious infinite-strength independence assumptions, etc.

[-]LoudFarts14y160

r_claypool provided some good links in that thread that addressed those issues. Additionally Lydia and Tim McGrew have penned a number of posts and papers dealing with the issues you raise.

I actually think that the topic could prove fruitful at a gathering in Salt Lake. Apply Bayesian principles and also discuss topics such as "belief in belief" and "fake explanations" prior to engaging the topic of Bayesian Mormon Apologetics.

[-]adamisom14y90

By the way, I'm a university student, discovered Less Wrong about 6-9 months ago, have read HPMoR and some of the Sequences (&plan to read more).

[-]ManDooD14y70

Count me in! I am working my way through the Sequences and would love to further discuss the key ideas contained within them! My journey from a traditional rationalist to a more LW style rationalist has been enlightening.

[-]hamnox14y40

YES.

Meeting suggestion: I'm particularly in love with the idea of formalizing chavruta pairs/triplets for specific learning/winning-at-life goals. (Studying, Weight Loss, Poker....) I find I already have many insane rivals, who are very good at dragging me into anti-logic and then beating me with experience, but none that are actually interested in winning. And studying in a vaccuum usually leads to lots of unrelated open tabs on wikipedia, at least for me.

Actually, I think it would be beneficial to talk about social-based hacks in general. Go all meta on why we're doing meetups at all. We're making an explicit point of gathering socially, so clearly we think there is some value to it...

[-]adamisom14y20

I'll have to look into that more, that sounds awesome! I had a vague idea of doing something like that too.

[-]DanielLC14y30

Interested.

Why can't the purpose of the Meetup be to meet up?

[-]hamnox14y120

We can, but as this case study points out, social/unfocused discussions usually have poor attendance because hanging out is harder to justify than having a specific purpose. It would be fine for a first meeting, probably, but I'd expect most would find more important things to do the second or third time around if we're not doing anything obviously useful.

[-]occlude14y40

My experience with similar groups bears this out, although I think I'd loosely construe "obviously useful" as things that make us better/stronger and things that are fun to do.

[-]DanNuffer14y30

I'm interested.

[-]Rukiedor14y20

I would be interested

[-]ksvanhorn14y20

I would be interested.

[-]occlude14y20

I might be interested as well.

[-]HeatDeath14y20

I'd be interested.

[-]hamnox14y10

Gah! Mid-January seems so far away...

Anyone here perchance frequent Mestizo's coffeehouse?

[-]adamisom14y00

I know where that is, there's an atheist Meetup that meets there, I think.

My original thought on waiting until Jan was to have time to plan ahead. Also, I honestly had no idea there were this many LWers in SLC!

[-]DanPeverley14y10

I would be interested. It'd be a bit of a drive, but I would make time :) It's good to know that there are more of you out here.

[-]Curiouskid14y10

I'm not a Salt Lake City Resident, but I'm going to be skiing in Utah over my winter break. I'm going be returning home around New Years, but if the meetup is before then, I'd love to meet you people. Previously I tried to make a meet-up in Indianapolis, but there doesn't appear to be anybody within a 60-mile radius.

[-]burnt14y10

I'm down!!!

[-]te_platt14y10

I am interested.

[-]ksvanhorn14y00

If you've seen my LW article on For-Profit Rationality Training, you know that Dan Nuffer and I are trying to put together a business aimed at helping people develop better instrumental rationality. As anyone who follows LW knows, if you want good ideas, you need to generate a lot of ideas. So... could I convince you all to participate in a business model brainstorming session with Dan and me, either as part of the meetup or immediately afterwards? What do you think?

[-]adamisom14y00

Maybe. I'd love all the help I can get to make a great LW Meetup. I think I remember seeing that article and having, um, strong positive affect (haha) towards the idea.

I'll get back to you - I plan on announcing the actual Meetup in 1 week and doing it in about 2 weeks.

[-]lextori14y00

I'm interested

[-]Curiouskid14y00

Anybody near/in Park City/? I'm skiing up here and would love to meet some rationalists while I'm at it.

Moderation Log

LESSWRONG
LW

LESSWRONG
LW

2

Meetup : Any Salt Lake City residents who might be interested in a meetup?

2

2

Discussion article for the meetup : Any Salt Lake City residents who might be interested in a meetup?

Discussion article for the meetup : Any Salt Lake City residents who might be interested in a meetup?