Background: Significantly Enhancing Adult Intelligence With Gene Editing, Superbabies
Epistemic Status: @GeneSmith or @sarahconstantin or @kman or someone else who knows this stuff might just tell me where the assumptions underlying this gambit are wrong.
I've been thinking about the proposals linked above, and asked a standard question: suppose the underlying genetic studies are Not Measuring What They Think They're Measuring. What might they be measuring instead, how could we distinguish those possibilities, and what other strategies does that suggest?
... and after going through that exercise I mostly think the underlying studies are fine, but they're known to not account for most of the genetic component of intelligence, and there are some very natural guesses for the biggest missing pieces, and those guesses maybe suggest different strategies.
Before sketching the "different gambit", let's talk about the baseline, i.e. the two proposals linked at top. In particular, we'll focus on the genetics part.
GeneSmith's plan focuses on single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), i.e. places in the genome where a single base-pair sometimes differs between two humans. (This type of mutation is in contrast to things like insertions or deletions.) GeneSmith argues pretty well IMO that just engineering all the right SNPs would be sufficient to raise a human's intelligence far beyond anything which has ever existed to date.
GeneSmith cites this Steve Hsu paper, which estimates via a simple back-the-envelope calculation that there are probably on the order of 10k relevant SNPs, each present in ~10% of the population on average, each mildly deleterious.
Conceptually, the model here is that IQ variation in the current population is driven mainly by mutation load: new mutations are introduced at a steady pace, and evolution kills off the mildly-bad ones (i.e. almost all of them) only slowly, so there's an equilibrium with many random mildly-bad mutations. Variability in intelligence comes from mostly-additive contributions from those many mildly-bad mutations. Important point for later: the arguments behind that conceptual model generalize to some extent beyond SNPs; they'd also apply to other kinds of mutations.
Based on a quick googling, SNPs are known to not account for the majority of genetic heritability of intelligence. This source cites a couple others which supposedly upper-bound the total SNP contribution to about 25% of IQ variability (using a method which does not require identifying all the relevant SNPs, though I don't know the details of that method). Estimates of the genetic component of IQ tend to be 50-70%, so SNPs are about half or less.
Notably, IIRC, attempts to identify which mutations account for the rest by looking at human genetic datasets have also mostly failed to close the gap. (Though I haven't looked closely into that piece, so this is a place where I'm at particularly high risk of being wrong.)
So what's missing?
We're looking for some class of genetic mutations, which wouldn't be easy to find in current genetic datasets, have mostly-relatively-mild effects individually, are reasonably common across humans, and of which there are many in an individual genome.
Guess: sounds like variation of copy count in sequences with lots of repeats/copies, like microsatellites/minisatellites or transposons.
Most genetic sequencing for the past 20 years has been shotgun sequencing, in which we break the genome up into little pieces, sequence the little pieces, then computationally reconstruct the whole genome later. That method works particularly poorly for sequences which repeat a lot, so we have relatively poor coverage and understanding of copy counts/repeat counts for such sequences. So it's the sort of thing which might not have already been found via sequencing datasets, even though at least half the genome consists of these sorts of sequences.
Notably, these sorts of sequences typically have unusually high mutation rates. So there's lots of variation across humans. Also, there's been lots of selection pressure for the effects of those mutations to be relatively mild.
With SNPs, there's tens of thousands of different SNPs which would each need to be targeted differently. With high copy sequences, there's a relatively small set of different sequences. So the engineering part could be quite a lot easier, if we don't need to do different things with different copies. For instance, if the problem boils down to "get rid of live L1 transposons" or "lengthen all the XYZ repeat sequences", that would probably be simpler engineering-wise than targeting 10k SNPs.
The flip side is that there's more novel science to do. The main thing we'd want is deep sequencing data (i.e. sequencing where people were careful to get all those tricky high-copy parts right) with some kind of IQ score attached (or SAT, or anything else highly correlated with g-factor). Notably, we might not need a very giant dataset, as is needed for SNPs. Under (some versions of) the copy count model, there aren't necessarily thousands of different mutations which add up to yield the roughly-normal trait distribution we see. Instead, there's independent random copy events, which add up to a roughly-normal number of copies of something. (And the mutation mechanism makes it hard for evolution to fully suppress the copying, which is why it hasn't been selected away; transposons are a good example.)
So, main steps:
(There might be a sorta annoying analysis one could do to test my hypothesis: On my hypothesis the correlation between the intelligence of very intelligent parents and their children would be even a bit less than on the just-independent-mutations hypothesis, because very intelligent people likely also got lucky in how their gene variants work together but those properties would unlikely to all be passed along and end up dominant.)