LESSWRONG
LW

1694
Wikitags

Pica

Edited by Yoav Ravid, jimrandomh, Fluffnutt last updated 12th Dec 2023

Pica is the name of an eating disorder where people eat non-nutritional items. An example is people with iron deficiency eating ice cubes; there is no iron in ice cubes, but iron and crunchiness sort of go together. By analogy, pica is also when people are missing something, and respond by doing something which doesn't provide it, or doesn't provide much of it, like watching sitcoms because they're lonely or playing Minecraft because they feel unproductive.

AllAmericanBreakfast suggests that pica is like Goodhart's Law, with the added failure that the metric being maximized isn't even clearly related to the problem you're trying to solve, giving two examples:

  • Evaluate your startup by the sheer effort you're putting in? That's Goodhart's Law. Evaluate it by how cool the office looks? That's pica.
  • Evaluate your relationship by the sheer amount of physical affection? That's Goodhart's Law. Evaluate it by how much misery you put each other through "for love?" That's pica

Related Pages: Akrasia, Goodhart's Law

Subscribe
Discussion
Subscribe
Discussion
Posts tagged Pica
131Experiential Pica
Alicorn
16y
113
63Nobody does the thing that they are supposedly doing
Kaj_Sotala
8y
6
41Rationalist Lent
Qiaochu_Yuan
8y
61
37Bug Hunt 2
alkjash
8y
17
61Silence
alkjash
8y
17
Add Posts