LESSWRONG
LW

Wikitags

Superrationality

Edited by abramdemski, et al. last updated 17th Nov 2022

Superrationality is a concept invented by Douglas Hofstadter. He thought that agents should cooperate in Prisoner's Dilemma, but the primary notion of "rationality" which had been deeply developed by economists, decision-theorists, and game-theorists disagreed. Rather than fighting over the definition of rational, Douglas Hofstadter coined the term superrational for the kind of rationality he was interested in.

Douglas Hofstadter did not publish a full theory of superrationality, instead focusing on the prisoner's dilemma and other specific examples to communicate his intuition. However, some principles can be clearly inferred from his writing, such as reasoning as if you have control over the other player's policy (in symmetric games).

Eliezer Yudkowsky shared the same core intuition with Douglas Hofstadter, but took the path of trying to reclaim the word rational for what he meant, in Functional Decision Theory.  As a result, LessWrong does not consistently use superrational/superrationality.

Subscribe
1
Subscribe
1
Discussion0
Discussion0
Posts tagged Superrationality
71Hofstadter's Superrationality
gwern
13y
21
47Superrational Agents Kelly Bet Influence!
Ω
abramdemski
4y
Ω
7
31Superrationality in arbitrary games
Ω
Vanessa Kosoy
10y
Ω
6
29Superrationality and network flow control
Alex Flint
12y
11
26Breaking Oracles: superrationality and acausal trade
Ω
Stuart_Armstrong
6y
Ω
15
8LINK: Superrationality and DAOs
somnicule
11y
10
86Three reasons to cooperate
paulfchristiano
3y
14
28Infra-Bayesian haggling
Ω
hannagabor
1y
Ω
0
24Conditions for Superrationality-motivated Cooperation in a one-shot Prisoner's Dilemma
Jim Buhler
3y
4
12Cooperation is optimal, with weaker agents too  -  tldr
Ryo
1y
22
10A Benchmark for Decision Theories
StrivingForLegibility
2y
0
5Multiverse-wide Cooperation via Correlated Decision Making
Kaj_Sotala
8y
2
Add Posts