This is a special post for quick takes by Morpheus. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
“Causality is part of the map, not the territory”. I think I had already internalized that this is true for probabilities, but not for “causality”, a concept that I don't have a solid grasp on yet. This should be sort of obvious. It's probably written somewhere in the sequences. But not realizing this made me very confused when thinking about causality in a deterministic setting after reading the post on finite factored sets in pictures (causality doesn't seem to make sense in a deterministic setting). Thanks to Lucius for making me realize this.
[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply
I made the comment over a year ago ... and the question was whether you read the comments in general.
It should be obvious that if the territory is deterministic, the only remaining place for possibilities/probabilities to reside is in the map/mind. But it isn't at all obvious that the territory is deterministic.
1Morpheus
I often do read the comments, though I don't really read that intentionally, so I don't have a good estimate of how often I read comments or how many I read (probably read most comments if I find the topic interesting, and I feel like the points in the post wasn't obvious before I read it). I scroll through the "Recent discussion" stuff almost never. So I miss a lot of comments if I read a post early on and then people make comments later that I never see.
The point is that there is often a good counterargument to whatever is being asserted in a post. Sometimes it's in a comment to the post itself -- which is easy and convenient-- and sometimes it's on another website,.or in a book. Either way,.rationality does not consist of forcing yourself to adopt a list of "correct" beliefs.