Even on current models with better tests, see here
Demonstrating various types of memetic spread of misalignment?
Actually do control
Build pipelines for red-teaming monitors and the agent itself. For the agent red-teaming, I'd put particular focus on checking whether it continues malign trajectories.
Scaffold integrated control features and other non-monitoring runtime control measures
Human response and auditing
Improving async and sync monitoring
Agent security features
Surveilling for rogue internal deployments (as in, building after-the-fact detection methods for rogue deployments)
These presumably will involve a bunch of manual scoring, so we'll need to build a process for it.
Analyze AI biases and epistemics and improve across many domains
Build the anti-slop/anti-mundane-misalignment coalition via doing ratings of AIs and applying some pressure to improve on these ratings. This could focus on a variety of related issues.
The hope is basically that there might be widespread interest in removing/redacting mundane misalignment and other non-misalignment behavioral problems that reduce productivity and large parts of this seem differentially good. So, if we could make this a salient metric, AI companies might improve this. A lot of the difficulty would be in measuring the problem reasonably well. There are a bunch of different ways to apply pressure or increase salience if we had decent metrics, especially if these metrics legibly correspond to a common problem that many people are running into.
Try to do various trend extrapolations on things here to argue we aren't on track?
Neuralese decoding prep: Make natural language autoencoders much better, build methods for extracting internal CoT, build better evaluations of how well natural language autoencoders work.
I sort of agree? I think the net effect on overall capabilites progress is pretty small and some of the action I proposed would hopefully divert people from generic capabilites to working on this type of (hopefully particularly differential) capabilities. But I agree that some of these actions would involve safety motivated people doing work that would shorten timelines (relative to if they did nothing / worked on areas with no capabilities externalities) and it could turn out this work isn't valuable.
I think for "Get AIs generically better at conceptual w... (read more)