For those reading this who take the time to listen to either of these: I'd be extremely interested in brutally honest reactions + criticism, and then of course in general comments.
Listened to the Undark. I'll at least say I don't think anything went wrong, though I don't feel like there was substantial engagement. I hope further conversations do happen, I hope you'll be able to get a bit more personal and talk about reasoning styles instead of trying to speak on the object-level about an inherently abstract topic, and I hope the guy's paper ends up being worth posting about.
I think it's a high bar due to the nearest unblocked strategy problem and alienness.
[...]
If you start stopping proliferation when you're a year away from some runaway thing, then everyone has the tech that's one year away from the thing. That makes it more impossible that no one will do the remaining research, compared to if the tech everyone has is 5 or 20 years away from the thing.