Musing on modern warfare:
Background: So throughout history, generals have faced a tradeoff between concentrating their forces and dispersing their forces. There are pros and cons of each. But depending on the period in history, and the war, the balance tends to favor one or the other, to varying degrees. E.g. in most ancient warfare the correct strategy was to concentrate almost all of your forces in a single giant army, which would then have a huge battle against the enemy's giant army. But in WW1, the opposite was true; both sides spread out their forces to such an extent that a 'front line' developed with trenches and artillery and so forth stretching across the entire continent.
Anyhow, it seems empirically that the war in Ukraine has seen the balance shift towards more dispersion. The attacking Russians have learned to send a constant trickle of small squads, rather than concentrating columns of tanks to attempt a breakthrough. People say that this is because scout drones detect concentrations instantly, before they even reach the front line, and enable such concentrations to be destroyed by long range fires, often before they reach the front line.
What puzzles me is that I have a theoretical argument for why the opposite should be happening. Probably the theoretical argument is wrong, but maybe it's a sign of things to come. Here it is:
Above we mentioned that drones have made time-till-detection of concentrated forces go down, enabling them to be destroyed by long-range fires. An important backgound assumption, I'm guessing, is that long-range fires are more cost-effective against concentrated forces than against dispersed forces. This is most obviously true with artillery; damage per shell scales linearly with the amount of enemy forces in the area where your shell might land. And artillery since WW1 has been the king of the battlefield, responsible for most of the deaths and a large portion of the budget.
Well, artillery is in the process of being eclipsed by bomber drones. Already they account for something like 5x more kills than artillery, whereas before artillery was the dominant killer, so this revolution has already happened but it's going to continue to intensify.
My guess is that the bomber drones will continue to get longer-ranged until they significantly outrange artillery.
Importantly, bomber drones' cost-effectiveness does NOT scale linearly with the amount of enemy forces in the area you are hitting. Because they are smart weapons -- they can hit an individual soldier almost as well as they can hit a squad, they can hit an individual vehicle almost as well as they can hit a column.
So... maybe concentrating forces will soon turn out to be a good idea again? Because if the main threat is enemy drones, who will instantly detect you and then hit you with bombs/kamikazes before you even get into artillery range, maybe you don't take less damage in expectation by splitting up into loads of small squads dispersed across the front? (Whereas with artillery, this would drastically reduce the amount of damage you take) Unless maybe the squads are so small that they can actually escape detection for a significant period of time. But probably as drones become better and more numerous this possibility will be closed off; everyone will be spotted all the time, and so the way to advance will be to use your own drones to destroy the enemy before they use theirs to destroy you.
Basically, I'm imagining a near future where the dominant strategy is to concentrate your forces into a big column and push towards the enemy. The primary weapon of your force should be long-range bomber drones; the idea should be that you destroy the enemy at a distance before they can send their own drones against you. If they disperse their forces, you can defeat them in detail. Both sides will have fighter drones to defend against the bomber drones; if one side concentrates forces and the other side doesnt, then small flights of bomber drones from the dispersed groups will have to try to attack a large concentration of fighter drones, meanwhile large swarms from the concentrated group get to overwhelm small flights of fighter drones defending the dispersed groups.
I've said this before but the analogy might be to naval warfare in the Pacific in WW2. A single battleship could beat a dozen carriers -- if it got in range. Which it never would. Carriers would sink them before they got in range, pretty reliably. So in practice battleships were much less cost-effective than carriers. And in practice, concentrating all your carriers into one fleet was better than dispersing them into a bunch of individual ships, because of basically the bomber-fighter dynamics described above.
So if this theory is correct, how do we square this with the reality / empirical evidence, in which the opposite seems to be happening and both sides are dispersing forces maximally?
Well, in order to do the concentrated attack, you really need to have most of your force be long-range bomber drones & associated launchers etc. Because they are things that will actually do the fighting, and you are relying on them to hit the enemy before they hit you. Also the range really has to be long -- it has to comfortably outrange artillery, otherwise your concentrated forces will get cost-efficiently wrecked by artillery as has happened the past few years in Ukraine. I think these are sufficient explanations probably.
Some napkin math & additional musings. I should say I'm not an expert nor am I devoting any significant amount of time to this so my conclusions are not even close to confident. This is all extremely lazy speculation.
Google AI summary tells me: Grad rockets have max range 40km with CEP of about 100m. Conventional artillery (Krab system in particular) has 30km range but 40km with fancy rocket-assisted projectiles, with CEP of about 50m. Assuming this is representative...
Same source says a single artillery shell costs in the low thousands of dollar... (read more)