LESSWRONG
LW

Personal Blog

21

Tell me what you think of me

by lukeprog
5th Nov 2011
1 min read
23

21

Personal Blog

21

Tell me what you think of me
12Incorrect
4lukeprog
9gwern
6dbaupp
4SilasBarta
2Wilka
0gwern
4Bugmaster
5gwern
1lukeprog
4Bugmaster
0lukeprog
0gwern
2lukeprog
-1gwern
0Bugmaster
3Jolly
3Arkanj3l
6Luke_A_Somers
1Arkanj3l
6lukeprog
1roland
0HumanFlesh
New Comment
23 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 2:36 AM
[-]Incorrect14y120

Perhaps you may want to invoke Crocker's rules?

Simply a suggestion, no further implications intended.

Edit: Actually, still with no further implications intended beyond simple curiosity: if not, why not? I would be curious if you think the concept is a useful tool in a situation like this.

Reply
[-]lukeprog14y40

Oh yeah. Added.

Reply
[-]gwern12y90

I've written a post on 2 years of my feedback: http://lesswrong.com/r/discussion/lw/j8f/anonymous_feedback_forms_revisited/

Reply
[-]dbaupp14y60

I apologize for making a discussion post that is all about me.

No need to apologise; you have contributed a lot to the site recently, so you deserve a post to yourself.

Reply
[-]SilasBarta14y40

This seems like a great idea! I want to do this for myself. (I've had the honesty box up on facebook for a while but no one uses it.)

Any easy way to set this up for everyone? (Btw, I bet you'll get a message from "User:"Clippy saying that you don't make enough paperclips or something...)

Reply
[-]Wilka14y20

This looks to be a Google Docs form (used for making surveys), it just has a single question which is a "paragraph text" field. It shouldn't take long to do the same thing for yourself.

Have a look at this help topic for details on making a form.

Reply
[-]gwern14y00

That worked fairly well for me; I have what I think is a working feedback form. (I mostly copied lukeprog's wording, but omitting the parts about SIAI and hopefully wording it more friendly.)

The tricky part was figuring out how to set up email notifications: you have to go to the spreadsheet version of the form, click on Tools->Notifications and work from there.

Reply
[-]Bugmaster14y40

First of all, I can't give you any feedback, because I'm fairly new here -- sorry about that. That said, I really like this idea of having a persistent personal feedback form. Somehow it had never occurred to me.

I'm curious, though -- what exactly do you do with the feedback ? How do you analyze it (beyound just filtering out the spam, that is), and how do you apply the results of the analysis ? Do you have some sort of a systematic -- or better yet, automated -- way of doing so ?

Reply
[-]gwern14y50

I doubt he gets very much feedback; no point in running any formal analysis on tiny datasets.

Reply
[-]lukeprog14y10

I have 16 pieces of feedback so far, but (by design) they are qualitative. This is a static feedback form linked from the front page of my personal website, so I expect feedback to keep coming in, but I don't plan to do a systematic analysis - at least not for many months.

Reply
[-]Bugmaster14y40

This may be off-topic, but after skimming your website, I noticed that you wrote the Singularity FAQ. At one point, I thought of submitting an article critiquing the FAQ, but decided against it, since this might be considered trolling. But perhaps I should submit my critique via the feedback form ?

Reply
[-]lukeprog14y00

Sure.

Reply
[-]gwern14y00

How many do you have as of today? (I have 9 in total.)

Reply
[-]lukeprog14y20

41.

Reply
[-]gwern14y-10

Thanks.

Reply
[-]Bugmaster14y00

Ah, ok, that makes sense. Still, once you get around to performing such an analysis, I'd be very interested to see it. Making quantitative sense of qualitative data is what AI is all about, after all ! (ok, ok, not really, but it's still a fun thing to do).

Reply
[-]Jolly14y30

I also invoke Crockers rules - and appreciate any and all feedback others wish to give me :)

Reply
[-]Arkanj3l14y30

I'm waning saying anything definitive because you've earned enough status on the site that I might succumb to the Halo Effect.

But I'll say this: I think of you as the exemplar for an "Everyman rationalist" -- what the X-Rationality approach to life can do for the "common" Westernly schmoe, which is to say, a helluva lot. You have succeeded both epistemically and instrumentally through your deconversion and your self-help; these are issues that are "closer to home" than the demands set by FAI research, and thus invite a larger audience into the fold. In other words, you cover a lot of ground and you do it well.

I hope to emulate your comprehensiveness, your happiness (and, of course, your Modafinil habits :P) while building the Vancouver Rationalists community in the coming months.

Reply
[-]Luke_A_Somers14y60

So far as I can tell, lukeprog wasn't inviting feedback here, but via the link provided.

Reply
[-]Arkanj3l14y10

Mm, that's right. Worth retracting? I don't want to seem unscrupulous.

Reply
[-]lukeprog14y60

Not worth retracting.

Reply
[-]roland14y10

Luke, I would be curious to see how you write your articles, the same for other top LWers:

http://paulgraham.com/stypi.html

Reply
[-][anonymous]14y00

Your articles and references are enlightening.

[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply
Moderation Log
Curated and popular this week
23Comments

Time and time again, honest feedback has improved my life. I have sought it out on many specific occasions, but now I have a static, anonymous way for people to give me feedback — for any reason, at any time.

You can give me feedback on my personality, my conduct, or the organization for which I work by following this link right here.

Thank you. I apologize for making a discussion post that is all about me.

I operate by Crocker's Rules.

Mentioned in
10What you think about them
7SI and Social Business
1SI and Social Business