LESSWRONG
LW

356
Wikitags

Functional Decision Theory

Edited by Yoav Ravid, Heighn, Mikhail Samin, et al. last updated 21st Mar 2025

Functional Decision Theory is a decision theory described by Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares which says that agents should treat one’s decision as the output of a fixed mathematical function that answers the question, “Which output of this very function would yield the best outcome?”. It is a replacement of Timeless Decision Theory, and it outperforms other decision theories such as Causal Decision Theory (CDT) and Evidential Decision Theory (EDT). For example, it does better than CDT on Newcomb's Problem, better than EDT on the smoking lesion problem, and better than both in Parfit’s hitchhiker problem.

In Newcomb's Problem, an FDT agent reasons that Omega must have used some kind of model of her decision procedure in order to make an accurate prediction of her behavior. Omega's model and the agent are therefore both calculating the same function (the agent's decision procedure): they are subjunctively dependent on that function. Given perfect prediction by Omega, there are therefore only two outcomes in Newcomb's Problem: either the agent one-boxes and Omega predicted it (because its model also one-boxed), or the agent two-boxes and Omega predicted that. Because one-boxing then results in a million and two-boxing only in a thousand dollars, the FDT agent one-boxes.

External links:

  • Functional decision theory: A new theory of instrumental rationality
  • Cheating Death in Damascus
  • Decisions are for making bad outcomes inconsistent
  • On Functional Decision Theory by Wolfgang Schwarz

See Also:

  • Timeless Decision Theory
  • Updateless Decision Theory
  • Superrationality
  • Introduction to Logical Decision Theory for Computer Scientists
  • Introduction to Logical Decision Theory for Economists
  • Introduction to Logical Decision Theory for Analytic Philosophers
  • An Introduction to Logical Decision Theory for Everyone Else
Subscribe
Discussion
1
Subscribe
Discussion
1
Posts tagged Functional Decision Theory
16Functional Decision Theory: A New Theory of Instrumental Rationality
ESRogs
8y
1
17Alex Tabarrok advocates for crowdfunding systems with *Refund Bonuses*. I think this might be a natural occurrence of a money pump against Causal Decision Theory pledgers
mako yass
4y
13
58MIRI/OP exchange about decision theory
Ω
Rob Bensinger
4y
Ω
7
94A Critique of Functional Decision Theory
Ω
wdmacaskill
6y
Ω
56
35AXRP Episode 5 - Infra-Bayesianism with Vanessa Kosoy
Ω
DanielFilan
5y
Ω
12
25Newcomb Variant
lsusr
2y
23
23Is it justifiable for non-experts to have strong opinions about Gaza?
Yair Halberstadt, Adam Zerner
2y
12
14Anyone want to debate publicly about FDT?
Bentham's Bulldog
2y
31
11Game theory of "Nuclear Prisoner's Dilemma" - on nuking rocks
Q
CronoDAS
4mo
Q
6
6Violent Unraveling: Suicidal Majoritarianism
mako yass
4y
3
4The omnizoid - Heighn FDT Debate #5
Heighn
2y
0
44FDT is not directly comparable to CDT and EDT
SMK
3y
8
39FDT defects in a realistic Twin Prisoners' Dilemma
SMK
3y
1
32Dissolving Confusion around Functional Decision Theory
scasper
6y
24
32Let's Discuss Functional Decision Theory
Ω
Chris_Leong
7y
Ω
18
Load More (15/38)
Add Posts