LESSWRONG
LW

207
Wikitags

Dissolving the Question

Edited by Yoav Ravid, abramdemski last updated 17th Mar 2021

Dissolving the question is the act of making a question no longer necessary: satisfying all associated curiosity, resolving all related confusions, but without answering the question. The classic example is the question "If a tree falls in a forest and no one hears it, does it make a sound?". The apparent paradox of the question is, in this case, resolved by pointing out the ambiguity of the term "sound". The question can be dissolved by distinguishing between "Sound" as referring to auditory experience and "Sound" as referring to vibrations in the air. 

“Many philosophers—particularly amateur philosophers, and ancient philosophers—share a dangerous instinct: If you give them a question, they try to answer it.” - Eliezer Yudkowsky, Dissolving the Question

Sometimes a question does have a strong answer as stated, but also needs to be dissolved. This is (arguably) the case with Free Will, for example:

  • If we do have free will, there's still an additional question of why so many philosophers would conclude otherwise.
  • If we don't have free will, there's still the question of why so many philosophers think we do.

This is (probably) not just a case of "the other side is being silly": there does indeed seem to be something weird about the question which deserves scrutiny.

In other words, answering the question doesn't fully address the confusion that the question represents!

A failure mode in this step is giving justifications instead of explaining the process itself. Arguing that the reason we have an illusion of free will was that it was evolutionarily adaptive falls into this failure mode, as it doesn't explain the cognitive algorithm which produces the feeling of free will, and so doesn't dissolve the question. This can also be thought of as answering the "Why" instead of the "How", or as failing to provide a gears level model.

Dissolving a question usually (always?) involves providing a cognitive reduction of the question.

See also: deconfusion, cognitive reduction

Subscribe
Discussion
1
Subscribe
Discussion
1
Posts tagged Dissolving the Question
156Dissolving the Question
Eliezer Yudkowsky
18y
123
93Were atoms real?
AnnaSalamon
15y
157
54Seeing Red: Dissolving Mary's Room and Qualia
orthonormal
14y
163
41Towards dissolving the mystery of consciousness
GeometryOfTheShadows
7y
7
37Dissolving the "Is the Efficient Market Hypothesis Dead?" Question
Alexei
5y
4
37The Truth about Scotsmen, or: Dissolving Fallacies
Tesseract
15y
36
32Dissolving Confusion around Functional Decision Theory
scasper
6y
24
26A cognitive algorithm for "free will."
DirectedEvolution
4y
27
24My current take on the Paul-MIRI disagreement on alignability of messy AI
Ω
jessicata
9y
Ω
43
16Dissolving the Fermi Paradox (Applied Bayesianism)
shin_getter
8y
10
14Dissolving Sleeping Beauty
Chris_Leong
5y
21
12Tarski Statements as Rationalist Exercise
Vladimir_Nesov
17y
10
11[SEQ RERUN] Dissolving the Question
MinibearRex
14y
8
7A bit of word-dissolving in political discussion
[anonymous]11y
40
5Dissolving moral philosophy: from pain to meta-ethics
Charbel-Raphaël
1mo
3
Load More (15/23)
Add Posts