LESSWRONG
LW

Wikitags
Main
LW Wiki

Mind projection fallacy

Edited by Eliezer Yudkowsky, So8res, et al. last updated 19th Feb 2025

The "mind projection fallacy" occurs when somebody expects an overly direct resemblance between the intuitive language of the mind, and the language of physical reality.

Consider the map and territory metaphor, in which the world is a like a territory and your mental model of the world is like a map of that territory. In this metaphor, the mind projection fallacy is analogous to thinking that the territory can be folded up and put into your pocket.

As an archetypal example: Suppose you flip a coin, slap it against your wrist, and don't yet look at it. Does it make sense to say that the probability of the coin being heads is 50%? How can this be true, when the coin itself is already either definitely heads or definitely tails?

One who says "the coin is fundamentally uncertain; it is a feature of the coin that it is always 50% likely to be heads" commits the mind projection fallacy. Uncertainty is in the mind, not in reality. If you're ignorant about a coin, that's not a fact about the coin, it's a fact about you. It makes sense that your brain, the map, has an internal measure of how it's more or less sure of something. But that doesn't mean the coin itself has to contain a corresponding quantity of increased or decreased sureness; it is just heads or tails.

The ontology of a system is the elementary or basic components of that system. The ontology of your model of the world may include intuitive measures of uncertainty that it can use to represent the state of the coin, used as primitives like floating-point numbers are primitive in computers. The mind projection fallacy occurs whenever someone reasons as if the territory, the physical universe and its laws, must have the same sort of ontology as the map, our models of reality.

See also:

  • Subjective probability
  • The LessWrong sequence on Reductionism, especially:
    • How an algorithm feels from the inside
    • The Mind Projection Fallacy
    • Probability is in the mind
Parents:
Fallacies
Subscribe
Subscribe
Discussion0
Discussion0
Posts tagged Mind projection fallacy
1292-Place and 1-Place Words
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
38
93Mind Projection Fallacy
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
91
108Chaotic Inversion
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
69
27Notes on Empathy
David Gross
3y
2
19Examples of the Mind Projection Fallacy?
fiddlemath
14y
35
143Probability is in the Mind
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
227
78[Intuitive self-models] 3. The Homunculus
Steven Byrnes
11mo
39
68A List of Nuances
abramdemski
11y
24
39Vanilla and chocolate and preference judgements
Swimmer963 (Miranda Dixon-Luinenburg)
14y
32
247Mysterious Answers to Mysterious Questions
Eliezer Yudkowsky
18y
160
202The Useful Idea of Truth
Eliezer Yudkowsky
13y
545
140The Curse Of The Counterfactual
pjeby
6y
35
129The Relation Projection Fallacy and the purpose of life
Academian
13y
42
93Detached Lever Fallacy
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
43
39Three Fallacies of Teleology
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
14
Load More (15/25)
Add Posts