This is a special post for quick takes by Jonas V. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Some musings on what makes good taste in projects / priorities
(Copy-pasting and lightly editing an off-the-cuff Slack message that I originally wrote in the context of investments / trading)
Is this idiomatically correct? I have only heard "good taste" used in reference to aesthetics and decorum not practical matters like you enumerate here.
I reckon it's probably a generalisation of "research taste" which means "good judgement about what kind of research to try and do". This is subtly different to the more typical usage of the word taste — like, "music taste" usually means "ability to discern what music is good" not "ability to discern what music to try and make".
When I googled "research taste" many of the top results are LessWrong-adjacent, but I did find this page on "cultivating your research taste" written by some academics in 2013.
Maybe someone with superior googling skills to me can figure out if that's the origin of the phrase.
Sounds completely normal to me? Maybe a Bay Area thing? But I feel like I've heard it from other people.
I have never in my life heard it used like that - the closest is when Steve Jobs would discuss the overlap of aesthetics and product at Apple, bemoaning his competitors "had no taste". All the written sources I find on websearch don't seem to suggest that practical decision making is a common or a go-to meaning. Not being from the Bay Area or knowing anyone there though -- maybe it is a localism?
The Wikipedia page for "good taste" redirects to Aesthetic taste with a big picture of Kant (the author of 'the Critique of Judgement' of which the first half is "Critique of Aesthetic Judgment". This 4 year old Forbes article closely associates "taste" with aesthetics, particularly "beauty" and subjective measures which are no longer dictated by social class. This editorial in Town and Country magazine explores the classist/elitist ideas of "good taste":
This more modern understanding of good taste as being completely arbitrary, meant merely to suppress whole classes of people in the service of a tiny elite, brings us back to Sitwell, Duchamp, and Dalí and their dismissals of good taste as being “the enemy of art”—something stifling rather than liberating.
And while language is a multifaceted and constantly evolving thing. The dictionaries and idiom lists seem to preclude anything that veers too far away from ideas of decorum and aesthetics:
1. An appropriate or acceptable amount of tact or discretion; a sense of what is proper or will not cause offense in a given social situation.
2. A refined, sophisticated ability to appreciate or make discerning judgments about artistic, aesthetic, or intellectual matters.
good taste. (n.d.) Farlex Dictionary of Idioms. (2015). Retrieved June 23 2025 from https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/good+taste
in good taste
idiom : proper and acceptable
“In good taste.” Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary, Merriam-Webster, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/in%20good%20taste. Accessed 23 Jun. 2025.