Dean Ball is, among other things, a prominent critic of SB-1047. I meanwhile publicly supported it. But we both talked and it turns out we have a lot of common ground, especially re: the importance of transparency in frontier AI development. So we coauthored this op-ed in TIME: 4 Ways to Advance Transparency in Frontier AI Development. (tweet thread summary here)
The reason why I don't want to do this is because when you split them out, implementing vote-weighting is much more confusing UI-wise, and I am strongly opposed to having any straightforward voting systems on LW be based on non-weighted voting. If I found a good UI for splitting them out while preserving vote-weighting, I think it could be better.
Unfortunately we're a fair way into this process, not because of downvotes[1] but rather because the comments are often dominated by uncharitable interpretations that I can't productively engage with.[2]. I've had researchers and policy people tell me that reading the discussion convinced them that engaging when their work was discussed on LessWrong wasn't worth the trouble.
I'm still here, sad that I can't recommend it to many others, and wondering whether I'll regret this comment too.
----------------------------------------
1. I also feel there's a double standard, but don't think it matters much. Span-level reacts would make it a lot easier to tell what people disagree with though. ↩︎
2. Confidentiality makes any public writing far more effortful than you might expect. Comments which assume ill-faith are deeply unpleasant to engage with, and very rarely have any actionable takeaways. I've written and deleted a lot of other stuff here, and can't find an object-level description that I think is worth posting, but there are plenty of further reasons. ↩︎
10Daniel Kokotajlo
Sad to hear. Is this thread itself (starting with my parent comment which you replied to) an example of this, or are you referring instead to previous engagements/threads on LW?