I should search especially hard for potential reasons I've got it all wrong, even if my stated reasons for my belief (that rational agents shouldn't pay to avoid information) seem axiomatic.
One reason I'm suspicious of your position is that I notice it's not very historically-grounded. A dispassionate evaluation of which norms lead to intellectual productivity should at least gesture towards intellectual communities that have succeeded or failed in the past. Without this, it's much harder to know if your conception of healthy intellectualism is actually tracking what works.
In my own explorations of the history of science, I haven't come across anything that clearly corresponds to the masochism you describe, which suggests that it's not an essential rationality practice.
Relatedly, I was recently reading Randall Collins' The Sociology of Philosophies, which argues (in the first few chapters) that emotional energy aimed towards developing one's belief system is a crucial component of becoming a great philosopher. It seems reasonable to model people with "listening disorders" as trying to preserve a kind of emotional energy that is sapped by criticism.
You might still think that almost everyone is doing this so badly that it'd be better if they just stopped doing intellectual work at all. But if "it's like eating disorders" is the best defense of the other side you can come up with, then you have a big blind spot, and filling in this blind spot should be a priority for you, even if it doesn't end up changing your overall conclusion.
I'm sure this is obvious to you, but those who claim to suffer listening disorders are typically doing so for political reasons. The strategy is to claim that commentator X is not interesting (plausibly a subjective or aesthetic claim) as a way to convince bystanders not to listen to X either, thereby lessening X's political influence. Joe Rogan was a frequent target of this type of criticism. Certainly many people might not appreciate Rogan's style of humor, but those who went out of their way to say so were invariably motivated by dislike of his politics.
I think this OP clearly applies to some people and clearly doesn’t apply to other people. I’m reluctant to broadly disagree, because we’re probably just thinking of different prototypical cases.
But insofar as this post arguably applies to me, I will defend myself.
I try to avoid content that upsets me unless consuming it has a benefit that outweighs that cost. For example, I don’t routinely read general world news (outside my professional interests), with narrow and rare exceptions. And I stand by this as a great idea (see e.g. 1, 2), mainly because I find it upsetting and addictive and distracting, and the benefits of being up-to-date on the news are tiny and don’t outweigh those very real costs.
By the same token, if someone is posting bad takes on a topic I care about (say, AI x-risk), then I find it frustrating and addictive and distracting, and that’s a real cost, and we can ask whether the benefits outweigh the costs. In some cases, yes the benefits do outweigh the costs. Maybe the bad takes are bad in interesting-to-me ways that fit into some foreign-to-me world-model that I would like to understand better, or maybe it’s a corner of the discourse such that I may want to rebut it (e.g. I’m much more likely to reply to bad takes from neuroscientists [because I can engage with their expertise], or from x-risk-is-dumb-because-LLMs-won’t-scale-to-ASI people [because I can concede their whole argument but then explain why it’s not a crux for x-risk], or from leaders at my own organization), etc. But in many other cases the benefits are very low, and don’t outweigh the costs. Like, my strong belief is that the benefit of me reading a bunch of Marc Andreesen tweets about AI are just very small; I think there’s an extremely low chance that I would wind up with importantly different beliefs, or take importantly different actions. So I won’t follow those people on twitter, or read their stuff (unless it’s been specifically recommended to me), etc.
(I rarely block on twitter because I never look at the twitter algorithmic feed in the first place. I use twitter-lists, which are more like a white-list, which I guess you would say is even worse than blocking. And I’m currently not famous enough and don’t tweet enough to get many unwanted replies.)
When you say:
They're protecting their egos from signal that would hurt their feelings, cocooning themselves away from information that might challenge what they would prefer to believe. Someone protecting their time might mute someone for being boring, but not for "being a dick."
I think this is conflating a couple different things. Again, I find it very upsetting to read about the state of the Ukraine war, and there’s not much I would do with that knowledge regardless, so I only catch up on my Ukraine war news a couple times a year. Am I “protecting my ego from signal that would hurt my feelings”? Umm, kinda? But not in a bad way. Am I tuning out from it because it’s boring? No, my actions there are specifically because it’s upsetting, not boring. Am I protecting my time? Yes, but my time is not the main thing, it’s more about emotional energy and mental health. And also, the time I’ll spend literally reading the words of the article is probably much smaller than the time I’ll spend feeling distracted and upset afterwards.
But insofar as this post arguably applies to me
It doesn't. I think you're doing the wholesome "busy and don't have time for whatever nonsense people are yammering about" thing that I admire. Counting emotional energy as a conserved resource to avoid a topic like the Ukraine war altogether isn't pernicious in the way that it would be if someone was following the war and selectively found only pro- (or anti-) Ukraine comments emotionally taxing.
No, I definitely find AI x-risk takes I disagree with to be more emotionally taxing than ones I agree with, and thus (other things equal) am more likely to avoid them. That was my main point, and I was using the Ukraine war as an uncontroversial analogy to illustrate the idea that when things are emotionally taxing, it’s an actual cost and there’s nothing inherently wrong with taking that cost into account when you only have so much time in the day and only so much emotional energy and mental health.
I think there’s a strong temptation to judge people you disagree with on meta-level grounds: they broke the rules of thinking, they spent their time incorrectly, etc. But it’s very hard, if not impossible, to come up with meta-level rules of that type that would lead to results we like in every case. Like, “listen equally to both sides” sounds nice on paper, but I sure don’t want geologists to dedicate precisely equal amounts of their literature-search time reading mainstream geology papers versus young-earth creationism papers.
Sometimes you just have to drop down to the object level. Sometimes the problem is just that people have gotten the wrong object-level answer on an important matter. Everything else is commentary.
I’m comfortable ignoring Marc Andreesen’s AI takes because I’m really damn sure that his takes are nonsense, having spent enough time and effort to reach that conclusion to my own satisfaction. Meanwhile somewhere in the world, there’s probably some guy who thinks analogous thoughts about Steve Byrnes’s AI takes, and consequently decides to ignore those. If I saw the latter happening, I would be sorely tempted to say that this guy is bad because on general principle, people shouldn’t ignore other people. But I can’t say that! It would be hypocritical. Ignoring people per se is not where I think they went astray. The problem is that you really really have to get the right answer on the question of which people to ignore! Again, no escaping the object-level.
You're right that "listen equally to both sides" can't be taken literally, but I still think it's possible to tell the difference between people being efficient and being evasive, even if the way we can tell doesn't compress into a crisp one-sentence meta-level principle. Our confidence that you could refute Marc Andreesen's AI takes if you wanted to justifies your time-allocation decision to not bother. I'm skeptical that the one who thinks they could refute Byrnes but just doesn't want to bother is really occupying the same psychological state, even if it's hard to prove that.
Not a definitive experiment because ceteris is never paribus, but if I offered to pay the Byrnes-dismisser to engage with you and you with Andreesen, I'd guess you'd be more likely than the Byrnes-dismisser to sigh and take the money rather than finding some other excuse to wriggle out of it. The disposition to wriggle out of it would be a clue that their subjective sense of "I could if I wanted to" isn't fully believed.
Anyone is free to develop their own dysfunctions. It's only when they mandate it for others that it becomes a problem, which is particularly intractable when the vector is prevalent implicit norms, enforced by the victims in themselves. It's important to avoid feeding the norms that induce dysfunction, giving them more power over the culture, but the people are not the norms.
(The whole conflict vs. mistake thing is arguably about litigating the relative influence of the rival norms, as opposed to growing the cultural content by introducing novel ideas. I think general techniques for sandboxing the norms and seeking out points of view contrary to your own perspectives could help with this unilaterally, without depending on a healthy ecology of norms in any given subculture, though that's the kind of aspiration that's maybe more appropriate in 1800s, not in 2026, near the end of time. But if the future survives, even in a greatly diminished form, these kinds of considerations might still be key to exercising human agency.)
It seems to me that most people can achieve their desired level of rationality without supererogatory levels of putting up with ugliness for two main reasons.
Hmm. I see myself as having a duty to at least occasionally consider the arguments of people who disagree with me, even if I find it upsetting. But I don't think I have a duty to put up with people being dicks. For example, I immediately block most people on Twitter who I see calling for the death of others, or expressing similarly vile opinions or value judgements. I would also generally block people for like, using slurs. I really don't think I am missing out on much because of this, you know?
There's also occasionally a situation where there's like, some guy who maybe says vaguely interesting things sometimes, and a lot of my friends write them off for being a dick, and eventually after being very patient with the guy I eventually see something especially dickish and come around to the idea that like, man, I wasn't even getting all that much out of reading things that guy says anyways, they're clearly kind of dumb, what's the point in putting up with the dickishness.
And like, yeah, I think I personally endorse my tendency to err on the side of putting up with dickishness for too long, but I don't think my friends who write people off slightly faster than I do are making a mistake. There's obviously like, a range of reasonable places to live on that trade-off curve depending on how much dickishness bothers you and how much insight you're able to extract from any given slightly dickish person and so on.
Being rude or disdainful to people seems like a counterproductive method to get them to agree with you. Given that you're already advocating a certain opinion, I think the primary effect of advocating it rudely is probably to polarize people against you and make them take you less seriously. I don't think this is a very good way to "exert social pressure."[1]
IMO, it is pretty easy to clearly state your opinions without being perceived as rude. (At least by rationalist standards of etiquette.) You might disagree, and maybe it is more difficult for you to do this than it is for most people. When you say that people want you to talk to them in a "precise" and "idiosyncratic" way, that sounds to me like this is fairly difficult for you?
But also, it seems like you're leaning into the "rude" language somewhat, e.g. by saying that people are "beneath you." Or maybe you're not leaning into it, but you just think this way in your head and translating it into the equivalent "polite" speak is slightly inconvenient and seems pointless to you. Or (for completeness' sake) maybe you didn't know that saying that people are beneath you is considered rude.
I claim that exercising and improving your ability to communicate your ideas without being perceived as overly rude would cause more people to engage with your opinions, be convinced by them, and offer you thoughtful critique. Therefore, if you want to "actively seek out counterarguments for your beliefs," I think it would be helpful to pursue this.
Maybe you simply don't care about the opinions of people who would be turned off by rudeness. If you literally don't care at all, then I suppose you don't have to try to appeal to them. This is a self-consistent policy, but intuitively it feels pretty odd to write people off entirely based on this one trait. And this policy could lead to you ending up in an echo chamber of other people who think that being polite is pointless.
Separately from whether or not you express disdain, I think disdain is a pretty counterproductive emotion for truth-seeking. My impression (which may be wrong) is that you actively cultivate disdain, and are proud of it. I think it would be more productive to cultivate a spirit of cooperation, curiosity, and even compassion, even for people you think are mistaken. For example, suppose you know somebody who is usually wrong, but they actually express a valid and interesting argument once in a while. I think if you feel less disdain for them, you'll be more likely to notice and update on this when it happens.
Why does disdain exist at all, then? I think it could sometimes convince bystanders who agree with you or are somewhat on the fence to agree with you more, especially if they already respect your other opinions. But I think it's very unlikely to convince the person you're disdaining, or bystanders who identify with them.
a counterproductive method to get them to agree with you
But I'm not trying to get people to agree with me. What if I succeeded in getting people to agree with me when I was actually wrong? That would be terrible! Rather than directly trying to get people to agree with me, I'm trying to reason well and express myself clearly.
IMO, it is pretty easy to clearly state your opinions without being perceived as rude. (At least by rationalist standards of etiquette.) You might disagree, and maybe it is more difficult for you to do this than it is for most people.
I don't think this is about skill. Rather, I think that for opinions people don't want to hear, there is a tradeoff between clearness and not being perceived as rude. I think that people who think it's "pretty easy" to avoid the tradeoff either don't have any opinions that people don't want to hear, or are fooling themselves that they're being clear when they're actually obfuscating. For example—
But also, it seems like you're leaning into the "rude" language somewhat, e.g. by saying that people are "beneath you."
Yes, because I think they're beneath me (along this dimension). I actually think that! If my goal were to not be rude, I could certainly craft a paragraph that alludes to that sentiment in a softer, subtler way that wouldn't be perceived as rude. But that would be less clear.
I claim that exercising and improving your ability to communicate your ideas without being perceived as overly rude would cause more people to engage with your opinions, be convinced by them, and offer you thoughtful critique. Therefore, if you want to "actively seek out counterarguments for your beliefs," I think it would be helpful to pursue this.
In principle, I can't rule out the possibility that selective self-censorship to avoid triggering people's sense of rudeness could pay for itself by incentivizing higher-quality critique. In practice, based on years of experience, I just don't buy it at all.
For example, suppose you know somebody who is usually wrong, but they actually express a valid and interesting argument once in a while. I think if you feel less disdain for them, you'll be more likely to notice and update on this when it happens.
I agree that this is a potential failure mode of disdain, but my current assessment is that I'm not suffering from it; I think I'm pretty good about acknowledging when someone has made a valid point separately from whether I disdain other things about them. But I wouldn't expect you to blindly trust my self-report on that: if you see me ignoring a real point due to what looks like disdain, please leave a comment!
Given that you're already advocating a certain opinion, I think the primary effect of advocating it rudely is probably to polarize people against you and make them take you less seriously.
I think rudeness communicates status. By treating your opponents rudely, you indirectly claim that their status is lower than yours.
This is why it is a mistake to engage with rude opponents. The audience may or may not be convinced of the truth of your words, but will take it as an admission that you indeed are lower status than your opponent.
(And for normies, status is way more important than truth.)
As an example, think about the atheism wars. At the beginning, many people were like "these atheists make a few good points, but why do they have to be so arrogant about the religion? if they were more polite, they would be less controversial, and maybe could make more people listen to them". But that impoliteness was strategic; it communicated that religion is not as high-status as it would like to be, and as a consequence, many people became encouraged to disagree with religion. That sounds like disagreeing with religion for the wrong reasons -- you should reject it for being false, not for not being as high-status as it used to be in the past -- but for many people, making the conclusion that something high status is false would be psychologically unbearable. (Also notice the asymmetry in the demand for respect. No one objected against e.g. priests treating atheists with contempt. As high-status people, it was their privilege to preach to the masses that their opponents are immoral and deserve to be tortured. It is only improper if a low-status person says something bad about a high-status person, not vice versa.)
So sometimes it is proper to say "my opponent is a retard", because you simultaneously express disagreement with their beliefs and with their status claims. Of course it is better if you also provide an explanation why your opponent is a retard.
It seems to me your proposed "healthy" way is more analogous to eating disorder than what you argue against.
"Eat anything you see that has non zero amount of calories"
Leaving aside the taste of things, like suppose you are starving, it's still wrong approach. Many things have too few calories such that energy that would be expended on digesting them would drive it into negative. Some things are poisoned. Some things contain infections.
And more, when you face many opportunities you should consider the opportunity value, some things are just not worth it as there are better things to spend your effort and time on.
Wild karma fluctuations on this one! (It was up to 44 karma at one point, then was recently at 34 karma in 38 votes, and is now down to 10 karma in 44 votes.)
I strong downvoted from 40something to 30something after seeing it in the new posts feed because you elide what I take to be the core of picky eater stigma, and because the whole analogy is very stupid.
Thanks. What is the core?
But I think my "masochism" is an essential rationality practice. It's not an idiosyncratic innate quirk of no consequence;
I'm totally with you that a healthy masochism is important, whenever the truth hurts. At the same time...
masochism
/ˈmazəˌkizəm/
Masochism is the act of getting pleasure, satisfaction, or relief from experiencing physical pain, humiliation, or difficult situations
Are you enjoying it? Like, are your feelings on this closer to "puritanical self flaggelation" or "spank me harder daddy"? Are you getting the aftercare you need in order for these pains to be fun?
Counteracting compressive forces lead to buckling whenever there's a dimension that isn't perfectly constrained, and perfect constraint is hard. The enjoyment is really important, because that's what converts it into a pull towards the truth.
"My rivals in my local intellectual scene are beneath me" is exactly the kind of ego-gratifying belief that people tend to cling to contrary to evidence.
Is it just an ego gratifying belief? I'm not asking for arguments or outside views, just what your honest and unqualified belief is.
To the extent that it might be, then maybe you're actually wrong. If so, where would you be wrong? You obviously won't know for sure, but what's your hunch? If you were to wake up one day thinking "Fuck. They were right. At least, somewhat", where would you expect it to come up?
To the extent that it's not... then you're just better than everyone else. According to you, at least. And that's fine. If it's true it's true. Notice what that feels like though. I don't get the impression that you're operating from a place where this is "just true".
I should search especially hard for potential reasons I've got it all wrong, even if my stated reasons for my belief (that rational agents shouldn't pay to avoid information) seem axiomatic.
"Should" is a suspicious word. What is the purpose of "should" if not to distract from what is? If "I should do X" is just shorthand for "Once I/they see what X does, we'll want to do X", then why not just spell out what X does, and test the hypothesis?
You should look into this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SN6FyOqylls
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/FPQuv8TwTLPLsrJCk/not-because-you-should
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/HqQ3CpMqQyaaLLKew/should-considered-harmful
I think I could beat my eating disorder—if I wanted to. [...] But I don't want to make a project out of it! I just don't![...] For my food aversion, contrary to popular belief, it actually just doesn't seem like a big deal health-wise, as far as I can tell.
You're starting to sound a lot like the people you hold disdain for ;)
So, in light of the analogy to my eating disorder, should I be more merciful to people with listening disorders? Should I stop openly expressing disdain for them in public forums, in timeless exchange for my not being disdained in social eating situations?
In light of the analogy to your eating disorder, maybe you should walk the walk. Resolve your tastes so that good foods taste good, and bad foods taste bad.
Not because you think "it matters", but because "Oh, but I'm totally getting away with avoiding this discomfort of updating my mind to match reality" is the least trustworthy thing you could think. Because it's best to follow the first principles in case you're wrong where you're most susceptible to rationalization. Because you never know what you'll find until you look.
And so that you can lead by example. So that you can find out from the inside what it feels like to actually be moved in the ways you want to see people moved -- going first yourself, and noticing what it took to get you there.
Or maybe not. But I bet you'd learn a lot, and that it would transfer more than you think.
But the analogy doesn't have much to say about the costs of each aversion if left untreated.
Contrary to your belief, the costs of avoiding ego threatening information just aren't that high. People are only doing it in cases where a) people are just being dicks and contributing nothing new, or b) their emotions aren't actually about truth at all. It's just better to work on developing your own beliefs with people who matter than to waste emotional energy on stuff that has nothing to do with truth, and you didn't address this because you have a big blind spot.
It's not that hard to know what stuff you can avoid getting away with. And you know that, since you're doing it with your health.
At least, that's what someone who you're trying to persuade would argue.
To the extent that my disdain successfully exerts social pressure, I'm pressuring people to override an involuntary Absolute No, which is so hard that most people are never going to do it.
To the extent that you're exerting pressure, you're pressuring people to avoid the combination of "I should do X" and "I'm not doing X". It's that dissonance between the two that is uncomfortable, and "I'm not doing X" is in the model, not the self.
So yes, one way out of that is to accept your Should, and to accept your diagnosis of their behavior, and then change their behavior. Just eat the carrot, Zack. Masochism! Virtue! You Should do these things.
Another way out is to find ways to not model oneself in a way such that your imperative is relevant to them. There's no pressure I don't think you're right about me. You can try to be so clear that this is difficult, but if I don't wanna believe, what're you gonna do about it? Especially if I have enough friends in the same boat to not be lonely?
Which way out of the pressure do you think is more likely? What do you think the consequences will be, on net?
What are you seeing in the comments, so far?
(strong upvoted, btw :))
This is a post significantly dedicated to arguing against one's own beliefs, although it does spend significant word count explaining (i.e. implicitly advocating) those beliefs.
Keyed.
That's a lot of words to explain that people block you when you are an arsehole online.
It sounds like you need to do the intellectual equivalent of eating your vegetables, and get off the internet, find some real people to talk to, and do the work of actually becoming an expert.
So, ironically, I would consider your comment here to be a bad, "arsehole" comment. But importantly, to me, the thing that makes it bad isn't that you're being hostile to me, but that you're not really engaging with my arguments (where I'm construing "That's a lot of words", "get of the internet", &c. as dismissal rather than engagement).
I run into a lot of people who consider themselves truthseeking intellectuals who are also incredibly fussy about what information reaches their eyes. They block at the drop of a hat, derail intellectually substantive discussions into mind-numbing litigation of minutiæ of "tone", and refuse to acknowledge a logical point unless it's been presented to them in the precise way that doesn't offend their (often idiosyncratic) sense of etiquette or "discourse norms."
It would be hard to communicate how much contempt I hold these people in. (Not because I couldn't find the words. Because they'd block me before I could communicate it.) I think they are ineffective and boring people whose pretensions to intellectualism are morally fraudulent; I think they are making the world worse insofar as they manage to trick anyone into conflating epistemic virtue with mastery of their impoverished form of cant.
To be clear, I understand that attention is a precious and limited resource, now more than ever. One must ruthlessly filter and prune one's information environment in order to maintain the signal-to-noise ratio, lest one drown in an ocean of slop. If someone is quick to drop out of conversations because they're busy and don't have time for whatever nonsense people are yammering about, then that person has my respect, and indeed, admiration. (Perhaps I should learn to one day have so much respect for my own time.)
But the people I'm complaining about are obviously not protecting their time from noise. They're protecting their egos from signal that would hurt their feelings, cocooning themselves away from information that might challenge what they would prefer to believe. Someone protecting their time might mute someone for being boring, but not for "being a dick." (In my experience, everyone who complains about someone allegedly "being a dick" is actually complaining about that person's refusal to suck theirs.)
It's not that I'm some kind of superhuman stoic who has no empathy for why someone would want to hide from information. I have feelings, too. Sometimes I procrastinate checking my email or the comment section when a tough conversation has been happening and I'm worried that someone might have said something critical about me that I would find upsetting to read. I avoid it because I just don't want to deal with it now, when I could deal with it some hours or days later when I'm feeling up to it. (I always feel better after I eventually work up the bravery to check, but this fact is surprisingly hard to remember.)
Crucially, however, I know that me avoiding my mail is my (temporary) reluctance to meet the responsibilities of being a grown-up intellectual. Managing my emotions is my job. I don't expect or want other people to refrain from telling me things that I might find upsetting to read, because the set of things I might find upsetting to read includes a lot of important decision-relevant information about the world.
Although I'm not any kind of superhuman stoic, I think I have developed a certain tolerance and even taste for criticism. The email-avoidance behavior only kicks in when I'm facing particularly heightened social risk when fighting with people whose opinions I have reason to care about. In contrast, being criticized by randos elsewhere on the internet is more amusing than anything else. It's flattering to be hated: it means that someone thinks you're important enough to be worth hating, rather than ignored by default (as almost everything must be in our information-rich, attention-poor world).
The people I'm complaining about often point to /r/SneerClub (a group of "haters" of our local intellectual scene) as the epitome of "bad" speech that one shouldn't be so much as tempted to look at, but my main complaint about Sneer Club is that they're just not that smart and almost never come up with any really penetrating criticisms. In theory, one might have hoped that a dedicated anti-fan club might be an indispensable source of valuable criticism, as people who hate you are motivated to search hard for all the things you're doing wrong, that your friends love you too much to tell you about or even notice. Unfortunately, in practice, they just go for the cheap dunks. Thus, /r/SneerClub mostly ends up being boring to me, although the novelty of having dedicated haters is worth enough passing interest that I did make sure to submit one of my particularly sneerable-seeming pieces there. (My submission got locked, but someone else's got 36 karma before the mods decided to delist it because "it feels for once like an actual bullying thing to post".)
Once, before blocking me on Twitter (for retweeting satire of Scott Alexander that they thought was too sneering), someone told me that my own masochistic taste didn't license me to inflict it on others.
But I think my "masochism" is an essential rationality practice. It's not an idiosyncratic innate quirk of no consequence; it's an acquired taste that I deliberately cultivated for my epistemic health. By nature, people instinctively cling to comforting beliefs and feel pain doubting them. In the absence of any reliable way to avoid clinging to beliefs in the first place, the only honest way to deal with the pain is to embrace it.
Without "masochism", people hide their heads in a bubble and never confront the less comfortable aspects of the world they're living in. The path I've chosen isn't always comfortable, but it has its own rewards—and I think it is substantially a choice, not an immutable trait like height. I think the people I'm complaining about could be more like me if they wanted to, and the fact that they don't want to disqualifies them from being serious intellectuals. At least along this dimension, they are beneath me.
But part of the practice of not being afraid of information is actively seeking out counterarguments against my own comfortable beliefs. "My rivals in my local intellectual scene are beneath me" is exactly the kind of ego-gratifying belief that people tend to cling to contrary to evidence. I should search especially hard for potential reasons I've got it all wrong, even if my stated reasons for my belief (that rational agents shouldn't pay to avoid information) seem axiomatic.
When I do the search, I hit on one analogy that keeps haunting me. So, I'm kind of a picky eater. It's not that bad (and it's not as bad as when I was a child), but most vegetables just don't parse as food to me. (Onions and potatoes are not relevantly vegetables.) I can tolerate peas and carrots in the context of a soup or a fried-rice dish, but I wouldn't actually just eat a carrot. Salad just seems like an Absolute No—not just, I'd prefer to eat it later (as I sometimes prefer to check my email later), but rather that it's just Not Food. I don't know why I'm like this, but I suspect it's more common than people are willing to talk about? This has occasionally caused awkwardness in social eating situations. [1]
The analogy is: just as I hold some people in absolute contempt for being so finicky about what information reaches their eyes (because I think the finickiness makes them less rational), maybe some people would hold me with the same absolute contempt, that I'm so finicky about what food reaches my mouth (because they think the finickiness makes me less healthy). If I don't want picky eaters to be treated with contempt in social eating situations, maybe I shouldn't treat fragile intellectuals with contempt in public forums. If I want to indulge my eating disorder rather than trying to cure it, maybe I should let them indulge their listening disorder.
To be clear, it's not a great analogy. The domains of information and food intake aren't that similar, so of course there are disanalogies that run in my favor. For example, I could say that my health is no one's business but my own, but that falsehood in public discourse affects everyone. Or I could point out that I'm not claiming to be some athlete with an optimally nourished body (where a suboptimal diet could expose the claim as fraud), whereas the people I feel contempt for are claiming to be truthseeking intellectuals.
But the power of the analogy is that it forces me to attend to the practical decision-weight of an involuntary Absolute No, rather than brushing it off with platitudes about idealized Bayesian reasoners. If someone tried to bully me into changing my diet with appeals to what an idealized healthy human would eat, I would be unmoved. I think whatever health deficits I'm suffering from my eating disorder are quantitatively small. By not being able to tolerate most vegetables (while otherwise eating fruit, legumes, whole grains, &c.), maybe I'm somewhat below the reference value in vitamin K1, or missing out on some non-essential compounds no one has heard of like zeaxanthin or glucosinolates? It doesn't seem like a big deal.
But then the people I'm trying to bully into changing their information diet could say the same thing. They might concede in the abstract that they're theoretically missing something by not being an info-omnivore but insist that the practical effect is quantitatively small. Whatever information they're missing out on by not being able to tolerate Sneer Club, they think they can fill it out from other sources. [2]
The analogy also stress-tests my haughty claim that the people I'm complaining about could be more like me if they wanted to. It's not that the claim is wrong, but the conditional is doing more work than I was giving it credit for. I think I could beat my eating disorder—if I wanted to. There's lots of interventions to try: figure out what exact dimensions the aversion is responding to, do repeated exposure therapy in increasing doses, get skilled at cooking. Acquired tastes are a thing. (No one "innately" thinks coffee tastes good, and yet I drink decaf coffee, because at some point I acquired a coffee taste that remained even after I started being scared of caffeine.) I bet I could acquire a vegetable taste—if I made a project out of it. [3]
But I don't want to make a project out of it! I just don't! One of the things that makes me most grateful to be an economically independent adult rather than a child is that I can control my own food supply. I buy and prepare the foods that I want to eat, and it doesn't have to be a problem if I don't think it's a problem.
I can make an effortful project out of changing my habits when I genuinely think something is a problem. As it happens, I have been adjusting my diet recently to address some health concerns—nothing immediately dangerous, just some suboptimal weight and blood sugar numbers that it would be nice to get down.
But when I looked up what interventions would push on the numbers, it turned out that my vegetable problem was basically irrelevant! For fat loss, the idea is that you want to run a calorie deficit while exercising (especially weightlifting) and eating a lot of protein so that your body knows it should respond to the deficit by cannibalizing fat instead of muscle; for blood sugar, there are some more complicated recommendations about limiting starchy foods and timing when and how you eat them. Neither requires me to learn to eat Not Food. Apparently, one of the main reasons to recommend vegetables for weight loss is that their bulk provides the sensation of satiety without actually being many calories, tricking your body to be less hungry despite the calorie deficit. But since I'm counting calories anyway (which seems to be working fine), I'd rather be slightly hungrier than suffer eating Not Food to manipulate satiety. There's no reason for me to incur pain and expend effort to fix my eating disorder specifically when there are so many other competing projects that push on my actual goals.
But again, the fragile intellectuals I'm complaining about could say the same thing. They already have their hands full doing whatever kind of intellectual work they do, whether it's studying social dynamics or mechanistic interpretability. They could acquire a "masochistic" taste if they made a project out of it, but there's no reason for them to incur pain and expend effort on that particular project. It's not the low-hanging fruit for improving the work they do.
So, in light of the analogy to my eating disorder, should I be more merciful to people with listening disorders? Should I stop openly expressing disdain for them in public forums, in timeless exchange for my not being disdained in social eating situations?
I'm tentatively inclined to continue being unmerciful. The issue is that I just don't think the analogy is that strong in the ways that matter. The analogy is useful for forcing me to confront uncomfortable information about how difficult it is to remediate a particular psychological weakness (aversions to information or foods, respectively). But the analogy doesn't have much to say about the costs of each aversion if left untreated.
I think information aversion is a major if not the primary obstacle to human rationality, on both theoretical and empirical grounds. When people fail to achieve the truth, I think it's usually because they're avoiding their beliefs' real weak points, rather than due to an insufficiently nurturing discourse environment. You can't get away with avoiding just the information that bothers you when the information that bothers you is threats to your current beliefs (as contrasted to, e.g., unrealistic horror movies that you can avoid watching without confusing yourself about the world outside of the movies).
For my food aversion, contrary to popular belief, it actually just doesn't seem like a big deal health-wise, as far as I can tell. (And if it were, it would be only my own concern.) I think I am getting away with just avoiding the food that bothers me. In a way, this is "luck": if the science had come out the other way, I would have to make some tough behavioral changes or face the consequences.
But if I am going to continue being unmerciful, I can at least strive to be more clear-eyed and empathetic about how much pain I'm dealing. To the extent that my disdain successfully exerts social pressure, I'm pressuring people to override an involuntary Absolute No, which is so hard that most people are never going to do it. So I'm making people's days worse for only a small probability of achieving the behavioral change that I claim is prosocial. I shouldn't flinch from acknowledging that.
I feel blessed that the punishment hasn't been greater than occasional awkwardness. Apparently, the secret to getting away with social deviance is that people have limited will to enforce normative behavior. My father made me eat a carrot when I was about ten, and I threw up on the spot. He didn't try again. Because, well—why would he? It was less work for him to let me keep being childish. ↩︎
In the case of Sneer Club in particular, I mostly agree, but these people don't stop there. ↩︎
When a friend microwaved kale, I noticed to my surprise that the smell did have a Food register to it. If I wanted to, I could make a project of seeking out such chinks in the wall of aversion, cultivating and making them larger. ↩︎