565

LESSWRONG
LW

564
Personal Blog

2

Random question about starfish

by Raemon
5th Aug 2012
1 min read
16

2

Personal Blog

2

Random question about starfish
21[anonymous]
1Raemon
6Richard_Kennaway
6TrE
4Raemon
0TrE
0Raemon
0TrE
5Raemon
0NancyLebovitz
2Nisan
0Raemon
0Wei Dai
0Alicorn
0Vladimir_Nesov
0prase
New Comment
16 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 8:28 PM
[-][anonymous]13y210

Short answer: It depends, and it varies by the type. "Starfish" isn't a very specific term, after all.

Taking extremes, some cannot survive any significant exposure to air; even a few seconds is lethal -- crown-of-thorns can easily rupture on exposure to air and leak all their body fluids out rapidly. Others, such as ochre stars (a common species on the Pacific Northwest coast of North America) pump themselves full of seawater and then cling tightly to a rock with their hydrostatic tube-feet, retaining water as a heat sink and simply waiting out the high tide. Even species that aren't especially resilient to air exposure may take days to fully die, despite having undergone lethal exposure.

Reply
[-]Raemon13y10

Thanks!

Reply
[-]Richard_Kennaway13y60

Is this leading up to an assessment of the accuracy of the parable about throwing a starfish back into the sea? (Punchline: "vg znqr n qvssrerapr gb gung bar".)

If you search inside this book for the word "starfish" there's a chapter-length telling of that story (the whole book being an elaboration of the parable), with some concrete details of what happens to stranded starfishes of at least one sort, on at least one beach somewhere.

Reply
[-]TrE13y60

I was searching for "asteroidea" (biological term for sea stars) on google scholar, and found the term "desiccation" alongside it. So I did a search for exactly that, but found no exact time spans. However, it seems like some sea star species have to survive periods of dryness during tides, so I'd say 12 hours should be about a maximum. Just a wild guess, though. It apparently matters if there is sun or not as heat will dry them out quickly.

Anyway, I learned a lot about sea stars in the process

Reply
[-]Raemon13y40

Thanks.

asteroidea (biological term for sea stars)

This makes my own searches make far more sense. Articles kept talking about asteroids and I was so confused.

Reply
[-]TrE13y00

Glad I could help (somewhat).

Reply
[-]Raemon13y00

Helped, at least insofar as I'm unlikely to be grossly wrong about something in a way the average smart person can debunk.

Reply
[-]TrE13y00

What is it? Some sort of story, a game, or an analyzing article?

Reply
[-]Raemon13y50

I like cultivating an air of mystery before a reveal.

Reply
[-]NancyLebovitz13y00

Humidity level should matter, too.

Reply
[-]Nisan13y20

I have a feeling that you're about to do something very interesting, and I look forward to bearing about it!

Reply
[-]Raemon13y00

Thanks all. Originally thought I'd get this done within a day or two, but right now its looking like about 2 weeks before I post the end product. (I want to believe next weekend, but you know, planning fallacy and such)

In the meantime... it says there are 13 comments but I see twelve. Hmrr?

Reply
[-]Wei Dai13y00

In the meantime... it says there are 13 comments but I see twelve. Hmrr?

There's an additional spam comment that has been hidden (presumably by a moderator, unless there's an automated spam filter here that I don't know about).

Reply
[-]Alicorn13y00

There is a banned spam comment. I remember banning some comments like it but don't remember if this one in particular was me.

Reply
[-]Vladimir_Nesov13y00

Reported to the bug tracker.

Reply
[-]prase13y00

Adding a comment to see how the number changes.

Edit: written 14 and visible 13. Bizarre.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Raemon
View more
Curated and popular this week
16Comments

Anyone know how long a starfish can survive on land, and if it matters especially whether there is a hot sun.

I promise this will turn out to be (at least somewhat) important and Less-Wrong relevant. Googling for the answer gives me a bunch of "wiki-answers" type sites that I don't trust and news articles that don't give me the specifics. If anyone either has marine-biologist cred, or better google-fu than me, I'd appreciate it.