LESSWRONG
LW

Wikitags

Technological Forecasting

Edited by steven0461, weverka, et al. last updated 23rd Nov 2022

Technological forecasting means making predictions about future technological advances.

One approach is extrapolating from past data.  Extrapolating an exponential quickly. leads to very large changes. Moore's Law, which says that the number of transistors on an integrated circuit doubles every two years, is the classic example. Bela Nagy's performance curve database, perhaps the most systematic attempt at such extrapolation, has found similar trends in many technologies. Ray Kurzweil is a well-known advocate of exponential technological growth models. On the other hand, an exponential curve is indistinguishable from the early stages of a logistic curve that eventually approaches a ceiling, and all real world exponentials fail to continue their growth.  Consequently any attempt to extrapolate exponential growth requires entertaining all the mechanisms that might curtail growth.

Another approach is expert elicitation, such as in the survey taken at the Global Catastrophic Risk Conference, and a survey of artificial general intelligence researchers on AGI timelines.

One could create probabilistic models more complicated than a simple trend extrapolation. Anders Sandberg has done calculations on timelines for whole brain emulation, based on an analysis of prerequisite technologies. The Uncertain Future is a web application (developed by the Machine Intelligence Research Institute and currently in beta) that works with probability distributions provided by the user to calculate the probability of a disruption to "business as usual", which could come in the form of either a global disaster or the invention of artificial general intelligence.

An important danger in predicting the future is that one might tell complex stories with many details, any of which could fail and invalidate the prediction. Models like that used in The Uncertain Future attempt to avoid this problem by considering outcomes that could come about in multiple ways, and assigning some probability to many different scenarios.

Blog posts

  • Long-term technological forecasting

External links

  • Changing the frame of AI futurism: From storytelling to heavy-tailed, high-dimensional probability distributions (a conference paper explaining the reasoning behind the Uncertain Future app)

See also

  • Acceleration thesis
  • Good-story bias
  • Economic consequences of AI and whole brain emulation
Subscribe
Subscribe
Discussion0
Discussion0
Posts tagged Technological Forecasting
196Birds, Brains, Planes, and AI: Against Appeals to the Complexity/Mysteriousness/Efficiency of the Brain
Ω
Daniel Kokotajlo
5y
Ω
86
59microwave drilling is impractical
bhauth
1y
19
47on neodymium magnets
bhauth
2y
6
339Beware boasting about non-existent forecasting track records
Jotto999
3y
112
138AI Timelines via Cumulative Optimization Power: Less Long, More Short
jacob_cannell
3y
33
119Christiano, Cotra, and Yudkowsky on AI progress
Ω
Eliezer Yudkowsky, Ajeya Cotra
4y
Ω
95
111AI 2027: Responses
Zvi
5mo
3
108Conversation on technology forecasting and gradualism
Ω
Richard_Ngo, Eliezer Yudkowsky, Rohin Shah, Rob Bensinger
4y
Ω
30
97Announcing Epoch: A research organization investigating the road to Transformative AI
Ω
Jsevillamol, Pablo Villalobos, Tamay, lennart, Marius Hobbhahn, anson.ho
3y
Ω
2
91More Christiano, Cotra, and Yudkowsky on AI progress
Ω
Eliezer Yudkowsky, Ajeya Cotra
4y
Ω
28
84Unbounded Scales, Huge Jury Awards, & Futurism
Eliezer Yudkowsky
18y
10
75Will we run out of ML data? Evidence from projecting dataset size trends
Ω
Pablo Villalobos
3y
Ω
12
62Gary Marcus now saying AI can't do things it can already do
Benjamin_Todd
7mo
12
59Which technologies are stuck on initial adoption?
Q
Vanessa Kosoy, Steven Byrnes
2y
Q
39
53Open Phil releases RFPs on LLM Benchmarks and Forecasting
Ω
LawrenceC
2y
Ω
0
Load More (15/69)
Add Posts